Backdrops

OSCR's picture

Hello everyone. 

Something i've been putting off has been backdrops. An important feature of a model railrad. A friend of mine doesn't really like the photo backdrops as he says it takes away from the modelled portion of the layout. But as one of the backdrop providers says on their website, a backdrop is a model too. 

I'm proficient with Adobe Photoshop and with editing I can produce a nice backdrop with high quality images, if I have them. 

I've used masonite in the past and even curved around the corners, but I don't have a car to transport the materials from up the road. It is cost effective. However, I've decided to go with foamboard from our Dollar store, cheap and at 2 1/2 feet wide, 20 " tall (that i'll have to ajust to proper height) as a starting base. 

Now, with a 10' wall, I will have seems. It 'seems' inevitable in photos of other great layouts with their fantastic backdrops. I went the same route with foam board 5 locations ago when I first started my Ontario South Central layout and tried to spackle and sand the seem. But it didn't work. I never got round to painting them before I was on the move. 

Here is a mock up of 1 foamboard I cut in half. As you can see there are wires from the lighting going vertical down the wall. Stapling the wires horizontally is an option. But I would prefer the backdrop meeting the ceiling at 20" tucked behind the lights.

My question to you, what would be the best method to hiding the seems? The backdrops on backdrop providers websites i've seen only come in at 6' feet max. And I would go with the most minimal design and layer my own images on top especially where road meets the wall, etc. And at their price of close $100 usd plus shipping to Toronto I just don't see it as cost effective as I won't be happy with the results. The other option is to design the backdrop and send to printer and get a roll with adhesive but I would need high res photos and I could intersperse them. Another thing I decided was to have taller structures, silos, maybe even a cel tower, where the seem meets. I once saw a layout here they had a seem in the backdrop,and a tall water tower just left of it!

So ideas please of what you do to make realistic looking backdrops without the eye being disrupted with the dredded seem problem.

Thank in advance,

Brad, Toronto

 

 

Comments

Same with drywall, or sanding?

...maybe some mud and tape, like you would use for drywall? But this wouldn't work so well with a foam board, which is more flexible than the dried mud.

Other suggestion is to glue the two ends (butt-joint) of the foam boards together, then carefully sand it until it looks smooth.

OSCR's picture

Glued ends

Thanks @Juxen for your reply. Yes I had taped the two foam boards together and mudded/sanded them. And wasn't happy with the results like a drywall would. 

The glue end to end is a good thing to do thanks for that! I was going to just back tape them together. When I paint the foam boards after your suggestion of sanding, maybe the paint could fill the tight gap? Worth a try.

Thanks!
Brad

Ontario South Central Railway, Toronto, Canada. 

OSCR's picture

Silos hiding gap

Here is an example of hiding a seem, directly under a light, with silos. This could be effective moving forward, but the photo is cropped. What to do with the balance of the 10" above? 

Ontario South Central Railway, Toronto, Canada. 

Michael T.'s picture

I used masking tape to join

I used masking tape to join foam core behind a layout once. It's still visible once painted but it's wasn't that noticeable from a viewing distance of a couple of feet which is how wide the layout was. If I were going to really try and hide it I probably would have chosen spackling compound over the masking tape rather than drywall mud.

Michael

Original member of the "Gang of Six"

R.I.P. Verne Niner. The time I got to know you was way too short my friend.

"We all model the prototype, to suggest otherwise is ridiculous"

My Pike, https://mrhmag.com/blog/MichaelT

 

OSCR's picture

@Michael T.

Yes I did the join the two foamcore with white gloss tape. And spackled it, not drywall compound. Sanded it and wasn't satisfactoy. I don't want two seems now. What do you do now? 

cheers,

Brad

Ontario South Central Railway, Toronto, Canada. 

mspanton's picture

This may be a good item to

This may be a good item to search on this site, as there is quite a bit of discussion on same.

I used Masonite, and may again, but would attach lineoluem to it to give me longer runs without seams. (next time...?!?). After all, how many tall smokestacks can you reasonably defend?

Like you, I fussed with the cost, so decided I would tackle it myself with paint. You might get these paints from a big box store, in quarts may be enough.

I first painted the upper 3/4 of the backdrop in a sky blue - used most of a gallon here, but it is a relatively large layout.

Then I painted in clouds by dry-brushing in wispy clouds in white - suggest you not overdo this step. Less is more.

Then I dry-brush painted the white along a horizon about 2 inches up (HO layout), feathering into the sky. This represents the hazy far horizon clouds

Then I painted in a blue/gray "far horizon" line that gave a clean line against the lowest white. It undulates just a little up and down.

Just below the blue/gray, and only an inch at most, I painted in a gray/green to represent the nearer horizon.  It sometimes was below, and sometimes above the blue/gray line, but only by a very little bit - 1/2 inch or less. Sometimes I dragged the brush up slightly to give the appearance of barely discernible treetops.

Lastly, and now with artists paints, I stippled in trees using Mars Black, Yellow and White (for birch trunks). 

In the towns, I had a bit of a time painting in the streets and far buildings, as I am too unsteady to make fine straight lines, but even clunky looking lines worked out. Here you might put a photo onto the backdrop and blend the edges with the colors mentioned above.

This photo was about the bridge going in, and the green drops much lower than the blue as I described above, because this is a river valley. But you can see the colors clearly here.

 

- Milt
The Duluth MISSABE and Iron Range Railway in the 50's - 1:87

My take on the issue

Bite the bullet.

Find a way to get some 1/8" hardboard delivered. It can be done and it's worth the effort. As to hiding the photo image seams......at least you'll have a solid flat base that won't be going anywhere.  

Alternates

Hi Brad

i have wrestled with similar issue too. Tried the Masonite approach with it painted sky blue and it was ok. Certainly better than the existing purple wall with “orange peel” drywall texture.

Later I added 2 sections of commercial photo backdrop. They looked pretty good at first but I had a hard time lining them up and the seam was still visible.  Plus I find the Masonite kind of a pain to deal with.  And the photo backdrop started peeling off after a few months.  That’s probably due to my poor installation and flat paint on the Masonite more so than the photo product.  

This shows the results on the left:

All this confirmed that another approach was needed as I have about 50 feet of backdrop total. So I just tore it all down and am awaiting delivery of a 50’ roll of blue aluminum trim coil to install as backdrop.
 

Product:  https://www.homedepot.com/p/Amerimax-Home-Products-24-in-x-50-ft-Bermuda-Blue-and-White-Aluminum-Trim-Coil-69124102/205664231

Technique: https://www.nmra.org/sites/default/files/sr201202_alumback.pdf

 

There will be zero seams now and nicely curved corners.  I can add clouds as desired. So this is an option you might consider.  All in with J channel and punch tool less than $150 for 50’ backdrop.  

 

jeff

 

EDITED to add links and picture.  

—————————————
“Think before you post, try to be positive, and you do not always have to give your opinion.....”
-Bessemer Bob
mspanton's picture

Another picture of my hand-painted backdrop

It looks a little on the pink side here - the clouds are actually white.

- Milt
The Duluth MISSABE and Iron Range Railway in the 50's - 1:87

Milt

The photo above showing your painted backdrop is beautiful. The ground textures and vegetation have an impressionist feel and the colors are perfect......yup, a winner!

 I'm a big fan of painted backdrops too. They've gotta be loose which is an advantage to a non trained "artist" and also allows the main subject to not be overwhelmed.

 Here's mine......a study in dry tones.wink

 


>> Posts index


Journals/Blogs

Recent Blog posts: