Railpro

I would like to know form anyone who uses this system if they also have a DCC command station installed on the layout were they run both systems together. The reason I ask is i have read in a few places and even on Ring Engineering web site that there loco modules in a loco can be run on a DCC layout using their controller. I am currently setting up my layout with a Digitrax DB150 command station and have started to set up sections using the PM42. I would like to know if I would have any problems just running Railpro loco modules over my existing setup which from what I have read sounds like will work. Im not interested in a debate of which one is better Im just looking for some answers to my question. There was another post on here that I read through that this happened to. I have been using Digitrax for a long time and I am starting to get into JMRI at a friends house. I just happened to find out about  railpro and right now I really like what I see. If I can use what I have noe the cost will not be to much for me to switch over. I only have 3 locos with sound and a bunch dcc ready. I have not emailed Ring Engineering yet. I thought I would start here looking for some answers.

Thanks

Willy

https://www.youtube.com/user/boxcarwill/videos

http://boxcarwill.blogspot.ca/

 

Search

Search the forums. Has been discussed here. The loco's can run on dead rail, DC layouts and DCC layouts.

Rich

Bill Brillinger's picture

yes...

I have RailPro and it works perfectly on DCC layouts. No problem taking your locos and a controller there.

I was so pleased with RailPro that I also became a dealer. ( www.pdc.ca )

There is a RailPro User Group that is a great resource and the members are very happy to answer any questions you may have about this fantastic control system.

Some great things are in the works from Ring Engineering too; including a new computer interface for programming and control.

- Bill
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Modeling the BNML in HO Scale, Admin for the RailPro User Group, & owner of Precision Design Co.

 

Digital control

DCC is only one way to control locos with digital signals. Rail Pro and another system via wireless. I think the NWSL system. Battery operated.

DCC  and DCS via the rail.

One system uses wireless Bluetooth. Smartphones. Battery operated.

Rich

...

If you still think of Rail Power versus Battery Power having anything to do with Digital Command, you have not yet learned to separate the Power issue from the Control issue.

For FAR too long, the people in this hobby have conflated Power with Control, be it the early days when you controlled the trains by varying the power level at the track, or be it the DCC days, where a digital command message is modulated over the very power stream itself.

Digital control does not care where the power comes from, nor what form that power has, for it is just power.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Benny's Index or Somewhere Chasing Rabbits

" If I can use what I have

" If I can use what I have noe the cost will not be to much for me to switch over." 

   The big cost difference is the hand held throttles, Rail pro costs close to $300 per throttle while DCC is about $100 each. Non sound decoders cost a lot more for RailPro ( no $15-20 utility decoders) but sound decoders are closer together in price. I think the decision would depend on how many throttles you think you'd need and how important having a touch screen throttle is to you? ........DaveB

Bill Brillinger's picture

it's more than touch

I think the decision would depend on how many throttles you think you'd need and how important having a touch screen throttle is to you?

Or how important 1 click speed matching is.

BTW: Street Price for a fully featured RailPro wireless throttle is $229 including shipping, not $300

- Bill
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Modeling the BNML in HO Scale, Admin for the RailPro User Group, & owner of Precision Design Co.

 

joef's picture

Key word is WIRELESS

BTW: Street Price for a fully featured RailPro wireless throttle is $229 including shipping, not $300

The key word in Bill's statement is WIRELESS throttle. DCC wireless throttles are closer to $200 each, not $100 each as quoted previously.

And as for running on a DCC layout, the RailPro demo video we did here for MRH was running on my NCE DCC equipped Siskiyou Line layout, and RailPro ran just fine.

Joe Fugate​
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine

Joe Fugate's HO Siskiyou Line

Read my blog

"Street Price for a fully

"Street Price for a fully featured RailPro wireless throttle is $229 including shipping, not $300"

     That's great if you can sell them for $229 the throttle price difference becomes about 2.3 times instead of 3 times. I think one would have to consider how many locos they'd be running to decide if the higher decoder price difference matters to them more than the ease of consisting and the touch screen? A good non sound DCC decoder is about $20 while a non sound Rail pro decoder looks to be about $50( which hopefully would drop if this product survives?). If they are planning to use all sound locos the difference is not as great maybe $70 for DCC and $80 for Railpro? Like most things modelrailroad the layout needs are pretty specific to the situation so I'd research it myself instead of looking at ads or commercial reviews which are mostly based on selling product, then decide based on what I really need to do the job.....DaveB

joef's picture

Not so

That's great if you can sell them for $229 the throttle price difference becomes about 2.3 times instead of 3 times.

I repeat - apples to apples is to compare DCC WIRELESS throttles to RailPro, so the price difference is more like 1.0x to 1.5x. If you've ever wondered about wireless vs tethered throttles, consider this photo from an op session on my layout and imagine how it would have been if we used TETHERED throttles ...

Wireless DCC throttles and lots of bodies on the Siskiyou Line

Joe Fugate​
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine

Joe Fugate's HO Siskiyou Line

Read my blog

"I repeat - apples to apples

"I repeat - apples to apples is to compare DCC WIRELESS throttles to RailPro"

    Hi Joe,  Digitrax UT4R is $96 and UT4D $107 including postage these days.....DaveB


>> Posts index


Journals/Blogs

Recent Blog posts: