GregD

Currently working on the design for an auto plant on my HO layout.   The space available varies from 2 feet wide at the narrow end up to 3 feet wide at the other end.   Total length is 26 feet, although a portion of that is eaten up by a turnback curve on the narrow end so it works out to about 24 feet of straight track.

One thing I can not determine for sure is the handling of the 89foot boxcars.   As most know, the ones with 8 doors went to GM plants while the 4 door went to Ford and Chrysler.   But why did the door differences matter?

One friend speculated that it was the door placement on the plant building that would dictate which type of car would be spotted there.   This makes sense to me except for the fact that all my information shows these large cars (carrying sheet metal parts from the stamping plant) were shoved inside the building.

Now it makes me wonder, did these large cars actually get pushed inside the building or were they unloaded via outside doors?   

If they did get shoved inside, why would the door placement matter?   Do the assembly lines inside the plant dictate were things would need to be unloaded anyway?

For those interested in the layout of a plant and its corresponding yard, I would encourage you to pick up the 1999 issue of the Layout Design journal (#22) which detailed the GemCo plant in California.  Mike Osborne wrote a great article detailing the trackage layout.

Anyone out there with first hand experience or photos?

Attached is a slightly out of focus shot of the space I have earmarked for this plant.  For some reason, junk always seems to collect right where I need to do construction.   But, no worries, once the benchwork and subroadbed are up, I'm sure the junk will accumulate on the TOP of the layout - right where I want to lay track!   That section of pink foam in back with a hunk of flextrack hanging off is 2 feet wide.   I believe the aisle at the far end is 5 feet, and then the rest of the layout on the right, which you can barely see, is another 2 feet wide.

Reply 0
dehanley

Auto Plant

A construction company that I worked for did some work at the GM plant in Fort Wayne IN.  60' and 86' Boxcars were shoved into the building with one continuous dock inside.  I can't say how it was for other parts of the plant since we were escorted on and off the site.

Don Hanley

Proto-lancing a fictitious Erie branch line.

2%20erie.gif 

Reply 0
Virginian and Lake Erie

junk in the picture

That's not junk, it is strategically located construction supplies and stowed items that will be placed under the layout, you are just farther along than many folks because you don't have the layout over top of it yet.

On a serious note, the cars may be pushed into the plant and the door placement of the cars may be due to the load restraint and rack systems inside the cars rather than unloading facilities per se. The shippers from the GM plants that supply the assembly plant may package things in a certain way that differs from the systems in use by Ford and Chrysler. 

With Chrysler being much smaller than the other two manufacturers they likely needed to choose one of the two methods already in use. One other link that could tie them together is the fact that Lee Iacocca left Ford and went to Chrysler and brought many other people with him.

Hope this helps with your issue

Rob

Reply 0
Ken Hutnik huthut

Indoor docks

I have been in both component plants, and assembly plants.  Both had internal tracks that ran the length of the building, thus the "dock" could be anywhere the boxcar doors were spotted.  However, given the shipping distance etc for parts, rail could have been abandoned in favor of truck docks.  I would say there is likely a prototype for which ever you choose to use.  You could could also you Google Map with satellite and street views to check out various plants.  Wikipedia likely lists every current assembly plant and parts plants.


Ken
My projects: Ken's Model Trains
Reply 0
WP282

Auto plant docks

I worked at the New United Motor Manufacturing Inc. (NUMMI) plant in Fremont, CA for ten years, beginning in 1996. At the time, the plant was still receiving front and rear bumper fascias for the Geo/Chevy Prizm from Mexico in 86' auto parts boxes, with eight doors. The parts and racks were light but bulky. The boxcars went straight in to the building, perpendicular to the outside wall. The siding was removed in 2000 with production of the parts brought in-house.

Older employees who had been at the plant when it was GM Fremont, said most of the sidings were set up that way, with docks set up to receive two to three cars with access to both sides.

WP Mike

 Modeling the WP Cascade Division, 1965 - 1980

Reply 0
Reply