James Willmus JamesWillmus

Rather than posting a link to my full review I've decided this topic is of enough interest for people looking to get into photographing or filming their model trains that I've decided to repost the whole thing, but edited to stay within a reasonable length for the MRH website.

If you'd like to see the full length review you are welcome to view it on my website's blog.

BTW, if anyone knows an MRH sponsor that sells this product I'd be happy to include that information here as well.

Photography and video production requires a source of light in order to create fantastic images and video clips. A solid lighting kit should be a staple of anyone into product photography, or in our case model trains.  I decided to get myself an early Christmas gift, a lighting kit I found on Amazon made by Neewer. You can find the kit for sale on Amazon here for $199 (May 2022).

The Lighting Kit

Two weeks ago the box arrived at my apartment. The entire kit consists of two lighting rigs and some accessories. Here’s a breakdown of what came in the box:

  1. 2x Neewer 480 Bi-color LED panel lights
  2. 2x diffusion panels for the panel lights
  3. 2x 120v power cords
  4. 2x aluminum U-brackets to hold the lights
  5. 2x telescoping 75 inch tripods
  6. 2x carrying bags for the light panels and accessories (no bags for the tripods)

That’s a lot of kit for $199! Opening the boxes and assembly only took about 5 minutes. Mostly it was a matter of tightening thumb screws. In addition to the lighting kit I also purchased a set of four NP-F batteries made for Sony camcorders. With these batteries, the Neewer lighting kit can be used away from power cords.

[DSC00967-1-1024x683]

The Light Panels

The core of this lighting kit are the lights themselves. They are made in China and while somewhat cheap, the finish seems to be mostly aluminum so things could be a lot worse. Neewer is known for making camera accessories and lenses, but they also make a wide range of studio lights and are generally a solid option. This kit is one of their cheapest offerings though so if purchasing this kit don’t expect bullet-proof quality.

On the front side we see 240 LED’s arranged in a 20×24 grid pattern. Half of the LED’s match outdoor sunlight with a color with a temp of 5600K, the other half match an indoor incandescent color with a temp of 3200K. Basically 120 LED’s are warm and 120 are cool. By mixing the brightness of these two sets of LED’s a wide range of color temperature is possible ranging from 3200-5600K.

[DSC00976-1024x683][DSC00977-1024x683][DSC00979-1024x683]

This allows the user to match most lighting situations with the correct color temperature. The front of the light panel also has a space to add a diffusion panel (included) or different color filters (not included). The diffusion panel makes the light softer, which is a major benefit to model makers who don’t want harsh shadows. This is one area of complaint for me. While the diffusion panel does something, in my opinion it doesn’t do enough to actually diffuse the light. Fortunately, there are many options out there that can diffuse light and I’ll be making a post about that in the future.

[DSC00972-1024x683][DSC00973-1024x683]

Diffused light on the left, bare LED's on the right.

The backside of the light panel has a plastic housing for the electronics that is approximately 7 inches wide, 4 inches tall, and about 1 inch deep. This plastic housing features two NP-F battery mounts, a power selector switch, and two knobs that control the intensity of the warm and cool LED’s separately. The controls are simple to understand and easy to use which makes these lights fantastic for beginners. The power switch also works as a power selector and the light can seamlessly transition between 120V power and 7.2V battery power without any flicker of the light.

[DSC00970-1024x683]

The Tripods

Another area of weakness in this lighting kit are the tripods, but it’s not really a deal breaker. They are made from flimsy metal and will get beat up easily. A couple of solid dents will render these things unusable. That being said, this lighting kit is not meant to be thrown around as luggage.

Consider for a moment the intended use of this kit. It’s meant to be a budget option for product photographers who do almost all their work indoors in a studio setting. The needs of a model railroad photographer and a studio photographer are very similar. If the intention is to light up subjects for publication in a magazine or to post on YouTube, a fancy, durable lighting kit isn’t really necessary. Instead what we need is a couple of simple lights that can do the job without taking up too much space or eating into our wallets.

[DSC00981-683x1024][DSC00982-683x1024]

In this regard, these tripods do the job just fine. They are able to extend up to 75 inches in height and when folded up they are only about 2 feet long. They can take the weight of the light panels just fine, though they are very top heavy when extended past head height so caution must be taken so as to not accidentally knock the light over and damage the LED’s.

If you feel that these tripods are too thin and fragile for your needs, the lights can be bought on their own for $81. However, since that only saves $10 it will be worth it to just buy the two light kit with the tripods.

Recommended Accessories

Batteries

To make the lighting kit more flexible you may want to but some additional accessories. The first that I would recommend are some NP-F batteries. There are many third-party options out there but I purchased a 4-pack of NP-750’s and a charger from PowerExtra through Amazon. The batteries have a 5200mAh capacity at 7.4V DC which on the light panels gives me enough juice to power the light at full intensity for around 70 minutes (light panel draws 28 watts maximum).

Diffusion Panels

Besides batteries, you may want to get something that does a better job of diffusing light. One of the better commercially produced options is a soft-box. As the name suggests, a soft-box is a collapse able box that encases the light panel, diffusing the light being created. It’s essentially a lampshade for a studio light. Looking on the internet there are a variety of options out there but since I haven’t tested any of them I’ll refrain from making a recommendation.

Colored Filters

The final accessory you may want to purchase for this lighting kit is color filters. For most people taking pictures of daytime scenes on their model railroad, color filters are not necessary. But for those who want to make photos or videos simulating dawn, dusk, twilight, night time, rainy days or any other lighting condition found in the real world, having filters makes the process easier. For instance, if making a photo of a night scene, using a deep blue or violet filter simulates a black light and gives your camera just a few more photons to work with, making a sharper image.

Would I Recommend This Kit?

Absolutely! If you are a model railroader who is looking to learn photography or videography to better document your projects or train layout(s) then this lighting kit will do whatever task you require. With a few accessories, this kit is flexible enough to handle a variety of different lighting situations. Reducing video grain or sensor ISO goes a long way toward making a sharp, crisp image. For less than the price of a locomotive you can have a basic lighting kit that will cover most of your needs.

Besides the two light kit, Neewer also makes a 3 and 4 light kit at a low cost. For another $70 Neewer makes a more advanced kit that has a wireless control option. This adds a whole new dimension of control for photographers and filmmakers. That is probably more than what most people require but it is an option.

I recommend buying through a website like Amazon that has a good return policy. If I have any issues between now and Jan 20th next month I can return the lighting kit and get a full refund.

Thanks for taking a look and I hope this review was helpful!

_______________________________________________________________________________________

James Willmus

Website: Homestakemodels.com (website currently having issues)

Reply 2
Greg Amer gregamer

Great review

Thank you 

Reply 0
jeffshultz

I've got quite a few Neewer lights

And this review basically encapsulates the product line - inexpensive, not suitable for hard use, but effective when used within their limits. 

orange70.jpg
Jeff Shultz - MRH Technical Assistant
DCC Features Matrix/My blog index
Modeling a fictional GWI shortline combining three separate areas into one freelance-ish railroad.

Reply 1
Loren Clarke lclarke1959
Yes, a most helpful review. Thanks for taking all of the time to provide us all with a detailed analysis. I am very close to pressing the "buy now" button.

Loren Clarke - Fort Worth, Texas

Modeling the Pittsburg & Shawmut railroad.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/pittsburgh_shawmut_railroad/

"Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above". James 1:17

Reply 0
Reply