Craig Thomasson BNML2

Modern packaging is well designed to protect your locomotive and all the fine details from damage.  But what do you do with used models that don't have a box?  Older Athearn Blue Boxes (and similar boxes) are fine until you start adding details like sunshades and plastic handrails. Then the box is too narrow and those details get crushed or bent.

I have acquired a few used locomotives with no box, as well as adding details to older Blue Box models.  Since most of the time I run on other club or home layouts, my equipment usually lives in storage boxes.  I needed to find a better way to store my homeless and "newly enhanced" locomotives. I came up with the following criteria:

  • All boxes are the same size for ease of storing and transporting
  • Locomotive is stored upright, not on its side
  • Able to easily reach in and hold locomotive by the fuel tank
  • Locomotive does not "slide" into the padding to prevent damage to detail parts
  • Locomotive can be inserted or removed in only a couple of steps
  • Padding should be sufficient for normal storage and transport, does not need to withstand dropping forces
  • No extra pieces of padding that can be lost or shift out of place.

This is the solution I came up with.  This thread will discuss the details.

3_173711.jpg 

Craig

 

See what's happening on the Office Park Zone at my blog: http://model-railroad-hobbyist.com/blog/49643

Reply 0
Craig Thomasson BNML2

Making the Box

I have been using similar die-cut boxes for storing my rolling stock for the last 30+ years.  When I first discovered them, they were used for packaging frozen steaks for restaurants, so I simply knew them as "meat packaging" boxes.  It took a while for me to figure out the correct packaging terminology. 

The box style desired is a die-cut Tab Lock Mailer Box with a roll-side, roll-bottom or roll-tuck locking lid.  This style of box has a lid that covers the top and one side, with the side having tabs that tuck into the box to lock the lid closed.  Another more common style is the tuck-top or "indestructo" mailer.  These are less expensive and come in a wider selection of sizes, but aren't appropriate for this case because the lid has a side flap that tucks down inside the box.  This makes it more difficult to arrange the internal padding, and they don't have a natural locking feature.

The box size I determined was best for HO scale diesels has internal dimensions of 12" x 3" x 3", which is long enough to hold anything from switchers up to the current SD70 and ES44 variants. After much searching online, I found a 11.5" x 3" x 3" box at Paper Mart  https://www.papermart.com/p/tab-lock-tuck-top-mailing-boxes/20607 . With shipping, the cost worked out to about $1.60 per box for a minimum order of 50 boxes.

First, we need to do some prep work on the box.

170148_2.jpg 

Normally, the front side of the box (bottom part of the image above) is folded up and held in place by the sides.  We want the front side to be able to open up, so we need to trim the top corners down about 3/4" as indicated by the green triangles above.

Several key box edges are cut parallel to the internal corrugation layer.  This can cause the locking tabs to catch or bind when closing the box. For the edges marked in orange, use regular magic/scotch tape to wrap and seal the edges.

3_170658.jpg 

Before folding the ends, measure and mark the center lines for the length and width of the box on the inside bottom.  Next, use a glue gun to glue just the back wall flaps to the side flaps.  Leave the front wall alone as we want it to be able to fold open and closed.

3_171717.jpg 

Use your selected locomotive to mark the location of the front and rear edges of the fuel tank. I glued a small piece of foamcore at each line to act as anchors to prevent the locomotive from sliding back and forth.  You can also use chunks of cardboard.  Make sure the scraps clear both the fuel tank and the trucks.

3_172835.jpg 

For foam padding, I have a bunch foam inserts from Bachmann On30 equipment so I didn't bother to find an online source.  I cut the foam into 3/4" square strips for the side pieces.  The rear piece (right) is 3/4" tall and located at the rear truck bolster.  This is tall enough to secure the body without putting pressure on the handrails and bending them.  The front piece (left) is about 1.25" tall and located at the cab.  The rear pieces are glued to both the back side and bottom.  The front pieces are only glued to the front side (not the bottom).

3_173027.jpg 

For the top padding, locate and mark places on the roof that do not have any protruding details.  I normally locate on one of the rear radiator fans and the other right behind the cab.  These pieces of foam may need to be a bit larger than 3/4".  You want the padding to be tall enough to apply just enough pressure to keep the locomotive from moving.  Then glue the foam pieces to the inside of the lid.

3_173616.jpg 

When done, your box should look like this.  An extra step I do is to cut off the side tabs on the lid as they aren't really needed.  Mark the bottom of the box with an "F" and "R" so you know which way the locomotive fits.

3_173711.jpg 

The box is complete! To close, fold up the front side, then fold down and close the lid.  You may need to trim the flap top corners a bit more if they don't completely insert into the sides.  The opening front allows more hand room, and also ensures the foam padding is always pressed against the model instead of sliding against it.

If you want to protect against more aggressive handling or an accidental drop, you could add additional foam pieces to the lid so they are located at each end of the body.  Or you could keep the lid tabs and glue foam pieces to them.

Craig

 

See what's happening on the Office Park Zone at my blog: http://model-railroad-hobbyist.com/blog/49643

Reply 0
Yaron Bandell ybandell

Awesome

Craig, that's an awesome solution for this storage problem.

One suggestion I have is to guard against foam rot by using a thin plastic film between the model and the foam. This way if it ends up in long term storage and the foam starts to rot and stick, it won't stick on the model but on the outside of the plastic film. I have yet to need storage like this myself and thus haven't looked at what thin plastic film would work best. I'd be hesitant to advice the use cling wrap without testing this first.

Reply 0
Wayne Knape WayneK463

Plastic film for locomotive storage boxes

How about archival quality page protectors for photos and documents? Just cut them up as needed.

https://smile.amazon.com/s?k=archival+quality+page+protectors&ref=nb_sb_noss   for example. Smaller quantities should available from local sources.

Reply 0
Craig Thomasson BNML2

Foam Rot

Foam rot is something that should definitely be kept in mind depending on how long things are stored for.  One of my main reasons for using Athearn and Bachmann foam is that some of the pieces I have are going on 30 years old now with no signs of deterioration, so they seem stable enough to use without too much worry of deterioration.  I don't know if foam rot is a characteristic of the specific type of foam itself, or if it's triggered by environmental issues like exposure to lubricants, etc.

Cutting up archival quality page protectors like Wayne suggested is certainly an easy option.  The protective plastic material Athearn is now using in their packaging between the model and the clamshell I think would also be ideal, but I'm not sure where one could find it in small quantities. The only thing to keep in mind if using something like that is you may need to add additional foam padding.  With the plastic, you'll lose some of the friction afforded by the foam to keep the locomotive in place, particularly for sliding end-to-end.

Craig

 

See what's happening on the Office Park Zone at my blog: http://model-railroad-hobbyist.com/blog/49643

Reply 0
KenMason

Other Storage Boxes

Take a look at boxes for storing baseball cards. I have used them for both locomotives and freight cars. The 5000 count boxes can hold a good number of the freight cars depending on the car length. I have even made cardboard shelves to create a second layer to double up what each box can hold.

Ken

Reply 0
Reply