railandsail

Cryogenic Plant & Helium Plant

 

Finished the coal mine track plans, and the base plate onto which the coal mine will be built. Now I need to turn my attention to the left and down that long ramp that will take the trains down along that side of the layout to connect back to the mainline. At the bottom of that ramp there will be an intersection of turnouts that will allow the trains to access the refinery area. The refinery area is going to fill that opposite corner, and include both oil products and propane products,....so oil and propane tank cars will be loading and moving around on these tracks on either side of the refinery.


Early on I had wanted to possible find a location for at least a small cryogenic plant along with a spherical storage tank for those liquefied gases. It stems from my long time fascination with those cryogenic tank cars. I bought at least 8 of them when BLI finally bought out those plastic ones. Up to that time I figured the only way I would be able to afford those brass cars was to kit bash them like Bobby Pitts did such an excellent job on.

 

Some of Bobby Pitts' work

https://forum.mrhmag.com/post/scratched-from-the-trucks-upsix-axle-tank-carpainted-12209668

Brian

1) First Ideas: Help Designing Dbl-Deck Plan in Dedicated Shed
2) Next Idea: Another Interesting Trackplan to Consider
3) Final Plan: Trans-Continental Connector

Reply 0
railandsail

Lets see, can I fit something

Lets see, can I fit something in that space between to two opposite ends of the layout, and outboard of that ramp of track? First off I needed a long track parallel to the ramp track that could allow for staging some of those tank cars that would be coming and going from the refinery. Perhaps I should have two such 'staging tracks' for the variety of tank cars involved, plus even some coal loaded cars might pay a visit.

By happenstance I placed some turnouts and spur tracks at angles off of one of those staging tracks. Here is what that looked like.

 

I randomly placed those spurs in 'pairs' thinking each pair could service a small plant each. And the spurs are long enough to accommodate two of those cryogenic cars. The small plants would be located in between those spurs, and might consist of spherical stowage tanks (have two already), short squat condensing towers, taller towers, etc.
 

Nothing set in stone,..just brainstorming.

I'm open to ideas,..suggestions?

 

Reply 0
railandsail

N scale kit

Saw this interesting kit in N-scale, imported from Japan


 

 

 

Reply 0
Deane Johnson

That car in your initial

That car in your initial photo is one tasty car.  I can understand why you like them.  Tons of character.

Deane

Reply 0
railandsail

Did you see some of those

Did you see some of those others on that link I sited?

%20ps800.jpg 

https://forum.mrhmag.com/post/scratched-from-the-trucks-upsix-axle-tank-carpainted-12209668

Also just google "cryogenic tank cars"

 

 

Reply 0
railandsail

Larger Spherical Tanks

Just thinking out loud,...I need to kitbash a couple of larger spherical tanks like those shown in the TomyTec kit,...rather than those Kibri ones. One of those Kibri tanks would barely fill up one car,...maybe.

Lets see I need to keep a lookout for a larger spherical ball of some sort....?

Reply 0
Deane Johnson

I did see the one you

I did see the one you pictured in the link.  I was totally amazed at the quality of the detail and the exceptional workmanship.  Those cars have so much character, I can hardly believe it.

Reply 0
twforeman

Large Spheres

Craft stores often have large balls of styrofoam in various sizes.

https://www.michaels.com/floracraft-styrofoam-ball-4in/10103221.html

Not sure what you would coat it with to make it smooth.

Reply 0
vggrek

christmas tree balls

christmas tree balls or plastic-acrylic balls. do a search

Reply 0
railandsail

Not at the top of my 'to do

Not at the top of my 'to do list', but I did a quick look yesterday, and it does appear as though there are lots of plastic ball possibilities,...then perhaps pvc pipe for supports?

I'm not so sure the Christmas tree balls would be big enough. I figure rough estimate I need about 5" diameter. The Kribi tanks are about 3.25" dia.

I saw where another poster had asked (on another subject thread) what businesses might be recipients of these cryogenic gases. I believe one might get an idea from the variety of the model cars that have been produced,...a variety of businesses. And since I have a variety of these cars I am not going to worry about (nor have room for) these recipients on my layout.

Reply 0
railandsail

Google View of plant in Ky

Quote:

Well, you may be able to get away with plain old large cylindrical tanks - here's a link to Google View of the Air Liquide Ghent, Kentucky plant.  I wouldn't be surprized if there's serious amounts of underground storage as well.  There does look to be a row of SMALL(relatively-ish) spherical tanks toward the SE, but they're small enough you don't need to use toilet floats to model them (maybe in O scale...).

Interestingly enough, the loading sidings' layout somewhat resembles your track layout, if you consider the main storage facility "in the aisle". In any case, expect to use lots of piping...

But I like those toilet bowl floats....ha...ha

That plant is rather big and spread out !

 

Reply 0
railandsail

Ramp down that side, ideas?

I'm trying to figure out what might be done to 'disguise' that ramp of track running down that side behind the cryogenic plants. The ramp can be seen rather clearly here, https://forum.mrhmag.com/post/cryogenic-plant-helium-plant-12213985

I did NOT want to make it some sort of man-made steel structure, but rather an 'earthly' structure. But it is pretty tightly sandwiched in between that mainline track running along the wall, and the siding/staging tracks for the refinery et al. That would make the sides of that ramp-roadbed/mound pretty steep?

Any ideas?

perhaps rocky base?

Reply 0
Ngineer

Terre Armee

That looks like a great setup there, with plenty of viewing angles.

If you plan on modelling a modern site google "terre armee", which is precast concrete system of reinforced earth, the concrete blocks on both sides of the raised embankment are joined with a steel strip. You could just print something like that, lasercut it or have a sheet 3D printed. Those terre armee walls go straight up, leaving the most room at ground level.

Reply 0
railandsail

May have to consider

May have to consider something like that 'terre armee'.

I was asked on another forum,..

Quote:
Is the goal to hide the track and ramp,  or you just don't want to use good ol' stone/brick/concrete retaining walls?

I'm NOT looking to hide the track, just didn't want to use an urban style retaining wall.

I'm imaging that nether the refinery, nor those gas plants are located in a city area,...they are in the country. So I guess you might say I'm looking for a country style retaining wall,...what ever that is?

Reply 0
railandsail

random pics

 

Maybe something like these rather steep roadbeds

?

 

 

 

 

 

There was a very specific reason I did NOT want any type of arched structure up here,...because I already have a extensive stone arch bridge on the deck just below,....

 

Reply 0
railandsail

Hopefully additional info/photos coming

Quote:
On Thu, Jun 24, 2021 at 10:17 PM Doug Geiger < gmry@comcast.net
Quote:
I have collected a lot of photos of air plants, unfortunately no plans.   I will drop some of them into the GroupsIO photos files if you want them.  I have a space for a small air plant next to my BOF, but have not built it yet.  I have started on a cryogenic tank car load/unload facility next to it, though using parts from a concrete pumper truck.

-Doug Geiger
Reply 0
GeeTee

Retaining wall

I think I would just use a retaining wall. Rock , masonry , or concrete ,see if this does anything for you http://sterlingmodels.com/rock-molds/ . Most of the time for slope earth you want to stay around 1:1 or 45 deg slope.

 

 

 

 

Reply 0
railandsail

Retaining Structures

I rediscovered some plaster castings I had acquire some time ago,  and had taken then under consideration. They were cast in one piece that needed to be cut apart into its various 'levels'.

The problem is they are a bit too thick for much of my ramp, and I don't think any portion of a mainline would consider such a construction, nor a ramp carrying heavy coal cars from that coal mine up there??
 

81640-1.jpeg 

 

81723-2.jpeg 

 

81805-3.jpeg 

 

81839-4.jpeg 

age(205).png 

 

They are pretty neat though.

 

 

Reply 0
railandsail

Link to Doug's photos of air plants

https://groups.io/g/STEEL/album?id=265383

 

...steps in the process

age(206).png 

Reply 0
railandsail

spherical tanks

I like the looks of those spherical storage tanks of the Japanese kit much better than the tall cylindrical tanks.

With my smaller available footprint area I may have to be satisfied with several of those smaller Kibri ones?

 

 

 

 

Reply 0
railandsail

cryogenic plants

Rather surprised that very few modelers have done some sort of 'source plant' for their cryogenic tank cars.

I'm still working on the lower level of my new layout, so even I have not taken time to expand on my ideas,...but some sales on these cars prompted me to think about the possibilities some more,....maybe more of those cars for me.

 

 

Reply 0
Hillyard999

prototype example - Praxair facility in greater Tacoma, WA

Brian,

Here are a couple views of the praxair facility in Fife, WA.  They might give you some inspiration for your layout.  You may need to select "aerial view"

 

Google maps

Praxair Inc - Google Maps

Bing maps 

Praxair inc - bing maps

Reply 0
railandsail

Thanks for references

Bing maps      Praxair inc - bing maps

 

That Praxair plant looks like it could have been the model for that Japanese kit,.....particularly those large cooling towers,......and except for the spherical tanks

 

 

Reply 0
Elwood_Blues

Here's a prototypical version

Here's a prototypical version of your grade. Embankment above retaining walls on both sides. Steep grade with sharp vertical curves, too.

South View

Looking down tracks

North view

Reply 0
nogoodnik

Large Christmas Tree balls

Brian,

Look a little harder for Christmas tree balls, as you should be able to find some that are in the range of 5-inch diameter. They are for outdoor use. Home Depot would be a place to start when they put out the Christmas decorations.

Joe W.

Reply 0
Reply