J A Smith

This is my first post to my first blog so if I screw something up #1, I'm sorry and #2 give me a head's up and I will try not to do it again.

I model the Middletown and Unionville Railroad during the middle 1930's to the middle 1940's. The prototype M&U has a long and very interesting history beginning in 1867 as a broad gauge branch of the Erie Railroad, then as a standard gauge connection between the New York Midland (O&W) Railroad and the New Jersey Midland (S&W), then leased to the S&W, then as an independent shortline that is still in operation today.

I try to model the line as accurately as I can within the limits of my available space, and my abilities. This is my 3rd or 4th M&U layout and I learned from the others that I have what I like to call "ADHD modeling syndrome". This is where I will start something and continue it until something else sparks my interest then I will work on that and so on. This left a layout that was, for me, very unappealing. Nothing was complete after years of work I found it unapealing and not enjoyable, dust and spider webs ruled. I tore it down and started from scratch...complete scratch, I removed walls added several dedicated electric curcuits, sheetrocked the walls and ceiling (the layout is in a basement) and epoxied the cement floor. The expanded room was needed for an expanded layout, working one town while my caboose was still in the last one was an illusion breaker. The new layout would be double decked with a gradual grade to lift it up to two decks. I also eliminated any duck-unders, I found removing layers of skin from my back to be another unenjoyable aspect of the other layout. I went with a drop down by the entry way. I was intrigued by the concept of layout design elements (LDE) which would mesh with each of the five towns on my layout. So I am building each of the 5 towns as an LDE on a "benchwork" of foam insulation with a 1X2 frame. The whole thing is hung off the wall on heavy duty adjustable shelf brackets. The whole system has worked out extremely well for me and if I ever need to move the whole layout can come with me.

The first LDE I finished was the town of Slate Hill which is 6 years old and I have zero issues with the lightweight construction. The layout photo's are not magazine quality, I just banged some out with a little hand held digital camera, but you will get the idea.

o2.jpg 

The photo above is from the M&NJRHS of M&U RR #6 going westbound at Slate Hill crossing Route 6 in 1940 on a caboose hop. M&U #6 was originally NYO&W #24 and was the most handsome engine owned by the M&U RR.

The photo below is from my Slate Hill LDE. The buildings are all scratch built from styrene with interiors and lights. The station plans were in Model Railroad Craftsman, the house I just did from photo's and it was compressed to fit the location. The model #6 is a Bachmann 4-4-0 with DCC and sound. I modified it some to match the prototype a bit closer but I'm no rivit counter. The caboose #51 (which is actually facing the wrong way, sorry) started out as a Walthers 4 window caboose that I added the freight door to.

o.jpg 

The photo below is from the same house with the scene on the front porch more prominent. I wanted to "liven it up a bit" and remembered the Norman Rockwell painting of the young Marine home on leave showing the gang at the local garage a souviner Japanese battle flag. I took some artistic licence and moved the scene to this front porch to show the joyous temporary return of this Marine to his loved ones (note the blue star on the service banner in the window on the front door). By this time this house had been renovated into at least 3 apartments (actually my Uncle's family would rent one out in later years).

After looking at this picture I think I can do something better for those white flowers in front of the porch.

s.JPG 

The layout starts in Middletown NY, where the M&U RR connected with the Erie and the O&W railroads. The M&U had a small yard here with engine facilities that it shared with the Erie RR. I have all my track down in the configuration that it would have been in the mid 1930's to mid 1940's. I have scenery and some details complete but this is where I focus my energies now.

g2.jpg 

The photo above is of M&U RR Brill Car #55 sometime between 1935-1940. The railroad had a contract with the Middletown School District to bring high school students to Middletown from the other 4 towns along the line. The car had just returned to Middletown from one of these runs and is being turned on the M&U's turn table in "DG" yard.

The photo below is my M-55 on the turntable in DG yard. The M-55 model is a brass import that I'm planning on upgrading with DCC, sound and NWSL Stanton Drive. I would like to have room for some interior details which would be displayed through all that glass. The turntable was also scratch built with a 1/4 inch phone jack pivot so it is removable. The model, like the prototype, are "armstrong" powered. I am working on the scenery from the back of this section to the front. I am struggling with the tiny clearance between the O&W mainline and the backdrop which is a quarter of an inch. With so many photo's taken in this yard the hill, trees and homes in the background seem like a "must have". A photo backdrop made from period shots might be the way to go, but I don't know how to do that and the only shots I have are black and white. The houses now are completely covered by trees...a chalange.

g.jpg 

 

h2.jpg 

The photo above is M&U #6 returning to DG yard with Erie 6000 series milkcars. It is passing the M&U's coal tipple located between Washington St. and Houston Ave. The tracks in the foreground are the O&W's mainline, the Erie main were on the other side of the tipple and down the hill.

The photo above is my compressed version of this scene. The O&W main are out of frame to the left and due to space I had to start the "farm track" siding at Washington St. which is under the rear of the caboose. The M&U shared a crossing flagman with the O&W because their main lines were so close at this location. Washington St. was also where the M&U would drop off and pick up high school kids before a new school was built much farther from the railroad and this traffic stopped.

h.jpg 

The photo below is a random shot at Lime Kiln Road, east of Slate Hill. I wanted to add some interest and anchor the era by adding the Works Progress Administration crew working on the ditches.

a.jpg 

I will be taking some more shots around the layout, maybe some more "general layout" photo's and a few more specific shots with some later equipment.

Thank You.

J.A. Smith Pres. & GM

Reply 0
DMRY

Very Nice

"Mr. Smith",

Welcome to MRH and I' m super happy to be your first response(hopefully).   Very nice modeling and keep posting pix.  Its been awhile since I've been over, but it looks like you' ve been busy.  Please keep sharing.

Chris

Reply 0
sea-rail

  That is really really nice

That is really really nice modeling!  Maybe I missed it somewhere in the text but what scale is this? Looking forward to updates and learning more about this layout.

Reply 0
Mendota Northern

Excellent modeling!!

Excellent modeling!!

Reply 0
Alexedwin

Very nice modeling &

Very nice modeling & descriptions

Alex

One day I might be modeling the Puffing Billy Railway, Victoria, Australia.

My location - Queensland, Australia.

Reply 0
J A Smith

Thanks Chris

You put the blog bug in my ear and you are the first response. Just came down to take some more shots.

Reply 0
J A Smith

Sea-Rail

Scale is HO. sorry

Reply 0
Joe Atkinson IAISfan

Well done

I really enjoyed this, and I'm looking forward to reading more.  It's always fun for me to see prototype photos followed by the modeled scene.

If you can, would you please post your layout plan to help me piece everything together?

Reply 0
johnybgood18

Very nice!

Although I am not a fan of vintage railroading, I can surely appreciate beautiful work when I see it!

Congratulations!

Chris

You can visit my layout Facebook page: Freelanced Perkins subdivision

Reply 0
numbersmgr

Welcome

Welcome to MRH and a hearty Well Done.

I also enjoyed your description and the photos - prototype and then the model.  I will be looking for more updates as you are able to post them.

Jim Dixon    MRM 1040

A great pleasure in life is doing what others said you were not capable of doing!   

Reply 0
Geoff Bunza geoffb

Great Modeling and Memories

Hi J A,

I too enjoyed your story and your modeling. I think you captured the essence of the M&U RR and that is a great accomplishment. I spent quite a few summers in Unionville and had relatives in Middletown. I remember walking near the M&U RR right of way on some very hot summer days. I still have a set of Microscale M&U RR decals I keep intending to use on a 44 tonner for interchange.

A small suggestion which some MRH staff passed on to me doing my blog: Start each entry with a short description and a picture, and put the bulk of your material in the first comment. In this way, when the comments go into a second page, only your intro is repeated at the top of each supplemental page-- more efficient & less redundant.

I almost forgot to mention-- there is quite a unique feature of that part of New York, and that is the very black dirt of the local onion fields. It might be an interesting scene to model.

I will enjoy seeing more of your work as well as other references to the M&U RR.

Many thanks.

Best Regards,

Geoff Bunza

 

Geoff Bunza's Blog Index: https://mrhmag.com/blog/geoff-bunza
More Scale Model Animation videos at: https://www.youtube.com/user/DrGeoffB
Home page: http://www.scalemodelanimation.com

Reply 0
J A Smith

M&U RR Layout 2

Here are a few more shots I just took. A bit more info about the layout. The M&U is going to be point to point but the Erie and O&W run around the walls in a giant circle. This way I can have some big time double main line running, live interchanges with the M&U and tons of switching on the M&U. The track is all flex that I modify a great deal. Front of the layout main line track gets gapped every 39 feet with fish plates. The M&U track gets some where between one-in-three to one half of the ties removed to get that "living on the edge of insolvency" look. Some of the foreground trees are made from sunflower stalks and roots.

1real.jpg 

The photo above is of M&NJ #2 passing the Slate Hill station going eastbound.

The photo below is my model of the #2.

1.jpg 

3real.jpg 

Above. The M&U's turntable and engine house in DG Yard, Middletown.

Below is my attempt. I'm happy with the turntable and enginehouse...the background buildings, not so much. The more I look at it the more I'm convinced that they need to redo that whole thing. I tried to do a 3D thing because the real houses  are at an angle to the railroad here. It didn't work.

3.jpg 

The photo below is my M&U 44 tonner #1. After the M&U's consolidation #7 died the railroad had to lease several S&W decapods. The feed dealers along the line (who also owned the line) pooled some money and bought the lines only new engine...ever. It is here running light to grab some boxcars of sack feed at the NYS&W interchange below Unionville.

4.jpg 

5.jpg 

The photo above is the Middletown Milk and Cream "A" plant in Slate Hill. This building still stands on the west side of Route 6 in Slate Hill NY. The current owner of the building was nice enough to let my photograph and measure the building, the ice house behind it and do a quick walk through. It has a full interior and is lighted. My attempt at modeling purple loosestrife, a wide spread weed, is there in the foreground. I think I can do better.

The photo below is Martin's Feed in Slate Hill, the only feed store on the line that never suffered a fatal fire. It is one of the first buildings I ever scratch built. It has full interior and lighting and, like all of my major buildings, it is removable.

6.jpg 

Below. This is the Middletown Milk and Cream "B" plant in Slate Hill. I had originally built it with clapboard siding based on the photo's I had, but after doing several research articles for the M&NJRHS on the milk traffic on the line data was unearthed that proved it was made from cement with a stucco finish. So I got the opportunity to do it again. The clapboard structure has been recycled into other buildings.

7.jpg 

8real.jpg 

Above, #6 is taking water on the mainline from the DG yard water tower before heading down the line.

Below, my version. The water tower is the only kit on my layout, the venerable Atlas model. I did add another spout on the turntable track lead like the prototype. Still not digging my backdrop, the process of taking pictures for this blog has been illuminating.

8.jpg 

Thanks.

J.A. Smith

 

Reply 0
TTX101

Welcome - you add a lot!

Your eye for replicating prototype scenes is phenomenal!  Any chance we could get a track plan?  You have obviously done a lot with your space - it looks like you have some neat tricks for extending your foreground into your background, so to speak.  Keep the photos coming!

Rog.38

 
Reply 0
DMRY

Johnson?

Mr. Smith,

Please tell me Johnson is done.  And Westtown.  Those were my two favorite stations.  Can't wait to see the rest.  Check out Tom Johnson's INRAIL blog about backdrops, he might give you some inspiration on your foreground to backdrop transitions.   More please!   Slate Hill looks fantastic.

CH

Reply 0
J A Smith

Geoff Bunza...black dirt

Geoff,

Thanks for the comments. I grew up in Howells Jct. right outside Middletown and my Grandfather had a fairly large black dirt farm, I know it well. We could look up the embankment and watch Erie Lackawanna trains on the main line join the Graham Line there while picking lettuce, onions and celery.

I have not found much interaction on the real M&U with the black dirt farmers, but during operating sessions I usually sneak in an mty. car to Johnson (my current end of line) for a load of onions. There were 2 plans to add extensions to the real M&U to connect with the L&NE which did use an Erie Branch through the black dirt to get to the huge New Haven yard at Maybrook. The L&NE was having issues with the Erie and were looking to the M&U-O&W as another route to Maybrook.

Thanks for the comments.

JA Smith

Reply 0
J A Smith

Johnson?

Johnson (JO), the shelf is up and the foam is down. Flex track is pinned to the foam and I do operate trains there. I have the JO station sitting there next to the Bordens Creamery but that is it. After I get Middletown Yard (DG) done JO is the next focus. The creek will be in the foreground, should be good looking when done, I hope.

Westtown is after JO. I have the location all pegged out, the plan for that LDE is done, the station is built and for some reason I saved a small chunk of the scenery between the feed store and the creamery from the last layout. I guess I really liked the way it came out?

I promised myself that I would control my ADHD modeling so I have to finish DG before I switch to JO.

JA Smith

Reply 0
lcutter

Looking forward to seeing

Looking forward to seeing your progress on Johnson. I lived there for 20 years. Even though the tracks were out of service, it was sad to see them get torn up.

Larry Utter

Greeley, PA

Reply 0
BOK

This is great stuff as short

This is great stuff as short lines are always fun to model and view. 

Any chance of seeing a shot of Unionville and the wye either the model or a sketch?

Thanks, for sharing.

 

Barry

Reply 0
bschneider

Amazing work!

Great to see the M&U live again!

Bill
http://home.comcast.net/~oandw/

Reply 0
TTX101

The war hero is a great detail!

The Marine showing all his home town neighbors the Rising Sun flag he captured fighting in the Pacific - that scene looks like something Norman Rockwell would have painted!

Rog.38

 
Reply 0
J A Smith

Current end of line.

Barry,

My current end of line is Johnson. I have a section planned for Unionville which will include the wye but it will be years before I get there.

 

JA Smith

Reply 0
J A Smith

Norman Rockwell Inspired

This image was my inspiration.

Unknown.jpeg 

Reply 0
Reply