Crusty Old Shellback

Ok I'm working on my yard design for my new layout. I'm modeling a transition era so I'm running both Steam and diesel. I've got a couple of design's I'm working with and have a few questions. I have a turntable and roundhouse that will be a main focal point. 

Here are my two designs and looking for some input.

My first design is your typical roundhouse and turntable with the engine servicing facilities layed out on the side/entrance to them. Here are the water tower, coaling tower, diesel refueling, washing area etc. The main line track will run in front of the roundhouse near the front edge of the benchwork.

My second design/thoughts is this. Move the roundhouse/turntable out to the benchwork edge. Run the mainline behind the roundhouse. But with this design, I don't have enough room to put in the servicing facilities. So I'm wondering how important it is to model them? Can I just put in a few items? Or just paint them in on the back drop? One advantage of this design is that I can do a cut away of the roundhouse along the edge so that you can see inside of it which adds more detailing to the model.

I guess this is more a function of operations. In that when operating, do you account for time to service the loco's? Do you actually park them at the fuel/water and sit for the amount of time it would take to service them? Or is it just kind of a given? I'm not sure how much actual true "operating sessions" I'll be doing.

I know it will make the layout look better to have all of the structures but just wondering about this. Or I may be able to put in Half structures on the back drop. My biggest problem with the whole section is that it's on a curve. 

My arms got too short so I've switched to G scale. Old steam and early diesel are my choice of loco. Scratch built is better.

Reply 0
Jurgen Kleylein

modeling engine servicing

Some people like to model the servicing as part of operations, but I suspect that is the minority.  Most people just use the roundhouse as a place to park engines when they aren't being used.  That being said, I'm partial to modeling the service facilities because they are interesting, and it's kinda cool to pose engines under the coaling tower or water crane (if steam) or by the fuel rack or sanding tower if they are diesels.  It's really a question of how complete you want your engine service area to be, I think.  You will need to stick the engines into the roundhouse eventually anyway if you want to be able to get others out.

Jurgen

HO Deutsche Bundesbahn circa 1970

Visit the HO Sudbury Division at http://sudburydivision.ca/

The preceding message may not conform to NMRA recommended practices.

Reply 0
Crusty Old Shellback

Nevermind

Nevermind. It seems that no matter how I lay it out, I can't get my second idea to work where I can get the locos into the roundhouse. It just doesn't fit/work. So it's back to modeling the servicing facilities.

My arms got too short so I've switched to G scale. Old steam and early diesel are my choice of loco. Scratch built is better.

Reply 0
Reply