eastwind

Recently we've had threads on How to fine-tune servo operation for turnout control and on Enhancing HO scale turnouts with magnetic point locking.

I was wondering if it might be worthwhile to use the magnet turnout locking technique on servo-controlled turnouts. I thought maybe it would simplify tuning as the servo would just need to get the throw bar close enough to the right position for the magnets to take over. There'd be no servo problems with servo buzzing due to the servo trying to throw too far, and no problems with derailments due to the servo not throwing far enough.

Has anyone tried it? Or does everyone feel that the tuning problem is not that much of a hassle to overcome and the magnets wouldn't be worth the hassle of installing?

Having not used servos, I'm also wondering whether over time they need to be re-tuned?

You can call me EW. Here's my blog index

Reply 0
barr_ceo

Servos and magnets...

The magnets won't close a point against the servo - servos are more resistant to outside forces than that, and if the magnets WERE strong enough to do that, then the servo couldn't open the points against the pull of the magnet. Nope, it's not going to work.

Just tune the servo, and use a wire that will give a little to connect the servo and the points.

Read my Journal / Blog...

!BARR_LO.GIF Freelanced N scale Class I   Digitrax & JMRI

 NRail  T-Trak Standards  T-Trak Wiki    My T-Trak Wiki Pages

Reply 0
Reply