J. M. Loll

Will the Atlas HO GP7 negotiate a 15" radius curve without trouble? I realize the coupler overhang might be a problem, but will it make it through the curve?

 

Reply 0
Prof_Klyzlr

No, Maybe...

Dear J,

Officially, Atlas says "Minimum 18" radii".
(They say it for a reason, and it's pretty unambiguous)

Unofficially, you've got (only) anecdotal evidence,
sourced from whichever modeller you happen to ask,
on track of unknown/indeterminate make/brand/type/installation quality,...

(Sure, there may be that one Modeller
who has spent decades perfectly optimising every element of their specific
   track-installation
+ loco tuning
+ car-selection
+ couplers

so that the resulting combination-of-factors "works without trouble" around a "nominal" 15" radii curve,

but are You willing/able/competent/experienced-enough to put in the same ammount of effort and diligence,
to confidently push-forward, and successfully replicate their results?)

FWIW, Personally, I wouldn't,
a shorter Switcher loco is the better bet for "without trouble" results...
(or, at least, stands a better chance of "bending the Min 18" radii R-o-T" than a longer/larger loco)

Happy Modelling,
Aim to Improve,
Prof Klyzlr

PS for the kind of small/tight-radii switching layouts you've been contemplating,
"uncoupling" (sorry) the coupler-swing/overhang geometry issues from the "will it traverse the curve" question really is a non-starter... unless you fully-commit to never running around the Tight Curve with a car coupled to the loco...


 

Reply 0
bobby pitts

WOW, that would look good!

WOW, that would look good!

Bobby Pitts

Reply 0
ctxmf74

Officially, Atlas says "Minimum 18" radii".

Probably best to stick to that and modify your curve radius. I once had a small layout with 15 in radius and it worked with short engines but I'd much prefer to step up to 18 in at minimum, just a lot more room for error there as far as coupler swing, engine truck flexibility, etc......DaveB

Reply 0
joef

Also check the cars

Also check the cars. 50ft cars on a 15" radius in HO will not even couple.

Joe Fugate​
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine

[siskiyouBtn]

Read my blog

Reply 0
Reply