James Willmus JamesWillmus

For the last several days I've been printing like a mad lad for an upcoming large product, but there was some filament at the end of my first 1kg roll that needed to be used up. Rather than waste it or save a bunch of scrap filament, I decided to test out some new part files designed on Fusion 360.  Honestly, I'm quite happy with the results of this testing!

I wanted to test the feasibility of making rolling stock and other model equipment by breaking down the model into assemblies that can be glued together like a kit. It took a couple of tries, but on the third go everything finally went together smoothly.  The model is a 28ft narrow gauge box car in O scale and here are the results of the 3D printer:

DSC00239.JPG 

Side view of the model with 3D printed sheathing.

DSC00240.JPG 

3/4 view of 3D printed sheathing.

DSC00241.JPG 

Side view of 3D printed frame.

DSC00242.JPG 

3/4 view of 3D printed frame.

DSC00243.JPG 

Bottom view of 3D printed car frame.

The assembly consists of two kinds of parts, a frame, and sheathing. The frame pieces interlock in the corners and are quite strong once the glue dries. I like having the option of not using sheathing if wood or styrene sheet would work better.  I do like how the 3D printed sheathing came out.  Everything was printed on my Ender 3 V2 and nothing required any kind of support. The part files consist of:

  • Floor frame
  • Side frame
  • End frame
  • Roof frame
  • Floor deck
  • Side sheathing
  • End sheathing
  • Roof sheathing

There are still parts I need to design which will make a more complete car.  These include:

  1. Freight trucks
  2. Truck bolsters
  3. Roof walkway
  4. Door assembly
  5.  Queenpost bolsters/beams

Small detail parts are probably best if they are made of metal rather than being printed.  Grab irons, queenposts, brake gear, door latches, etc... would be more durable if they were made of white metal or brass.

My assembly process to get this far has been to first print the frame pieces.  Depending on the scale and size of the printer, this should take one or two print sessions.  The sheathing is then printed, also in one or two batches. I glued together the ends, sides, and roof frame and at the same time glued the deck onto the car floor frame. Once both assemblies were dry, I glued the car body to the car floor.  Once the frame was dry, the sheathing pieces were added.  I stopped at this point because I want this model to be a prototype and demonstration of how the pieces fit together.

I'm happy with the result because it is a square freight car that didn't take too long to put together on a work bench.  None of the pieces required support structures or special printing techniques, they just printed right onto the bed. Using the weight of the individual parts in grams, a model should only cost about $3.00 in PLA filament.  That includes the parts I have yet to completely design, so that figure is an estimation. Wheels, couplers, detail parts, paint, decals, and weathering would add to the cost, but ideally this would be about $15-20 per car.  The biggest benefit that I can see here is that now there's an option to make rolling stock and equipment from unique prototypes, or have something that looks different from what major manufacturers sells.

If anyone is interested, I'll be happy to share the files. I don't know how to post them up here though, so I'll have to look into that.

_______________________________________________________________________________________

James Willmus

Website: Homestakemodels.com (website currently having issues)

Reply 0
James Willmus JamesWillmus

Forgot to mention

Also, I should note that the pictures of the sheathing make it look harsh because I experimented with what sanding down the sides looks like.  I didn't like the result, so perhaps removing stray fibers with acetone or a lint roller would be a better idea.  The larger lines visible on the sheathing are intentional, as the part files have V grooves every 3 scale inches.

_______________________________________________________________________________________

James Willmus

Website: Homestakemodels.com (website currently having issues)

Reply 0
Jim at BSME

File posting

If you click on the add link icon, probably on the second row of tools towards the end, you can use that to upload files to the server.

Once you upload them, you create a link to that file, you could put a Display text like Frame, sheathing, etc or just leave that blank and it will put the link path to the file.

Alternately you could create a thingiverse account and put the files there. 

https://www.thingiverse.com/

Awesome work by the way, thanks for sharing.

- Jim B.
Baltimore Society of Model Engineers, Estd. 1932
O & HO Scale model railroading
Check out BSME on: FacebookInstagram
Reply 0
mark_h_charles

this is great work

This is great work! Thank you for sharing it.

Modeling most freight cars in 1:64 or 1:48 scales by 3-d printing must take account of the size limitation of most printers. Your 28-foot car in 1:48 (7 actual inches) is a tight squeeze.

I'm modeling a 40-foot flat car in 1:64 scale -- about 7.5 inches.

Your separation of frame and sheathing seems like a good idea.

Mark Charles

Reply 0
James Willmus JamesWillmus

Frame size

Yes, it is a tight squeeze for this specific printer.  However, it's possible to get larger printers.  Creality is even creating a 'conveyor belt' style printer that will be able to print an object of infinite length.  Not sure how much that will cost, but for people modeling larger scales, this is an incredible concept.

I'm also liking the separation of the sheath and framing because if it the sheathing doesn't turn out right, that step can be skipped and replaced with stuff made on the work bench.  I'm not designing this to replace scratchbuilding, but rather to make my work more consistent and save a bit of time.  I tried making cars completely from wood and, while possible, it felt a bit unneeded when most of those pieces will never be seen. This concept allows people to print out a blank canvas upon which they can make their own creations.

_______________________________________________________________________________________

James Willmus

Website: Homestakemodels.com (website currently having issues)

Reply 0
Reply