Yannis

Hi all,

I have almost finished designing my future layout destined for a permanent future house (when the time comes...), that fits the prototype/locale i like.

Following this design for the future, i realized the serious shortcomings of my current temporary layout (i rent... and it was designed with much less experience/knowledge at hand). So as a result, I have been thinking of ways to change it so that it adapts more to my current needs/wants and to try to capture the flavor of the aforementioned future / permanent layout. Working on the current layout is sort of a compromise, and i would much rather be working for the future layout.

While recently reading about the TOMA approach in various threads in the forum and following some discussion involving roll-out sections in another thread of mine (accessing deep urban scenes) i think i might have found one of the best possible solutions to my problem (of wanting to start working on the future layout now...and not wait for when i have the future house/space available). So i wanted to double check this idea with you, that you have much more experience than me on the TOMA concept.

The idea is, based/inspired  on/by the TOMA approach, to "cut" a few key scenes/pieces-sections out of the future layout design, "paste" them on my current space, and join them with "disposable" (only track will be salvaged at best) "filler" modules. So in the end i will have the benefit of building and seeing/operating actual parts of the future layout now, and possibly end up with a more realistic (imho) and satisfying layout now.

Key point is that the key-sections will fit perfectly the future layout / space as they are the actual sections of the future layout, and it is the "filler-sections" that will actually make them fit into the current space and in combination create the current layout.

Looking forward to your feedback on if i understood TOMA right and if this idea makes sense.

Many thanks in advance for your time

Yannis

Read my blog

Reply 0
joef

Yep, you got it

Yep, you got it. That's one of the key TOMA concepts ... build your layout in bite-sized pieces and then when you relocate, take them with you.

Another key concept of TOMA is temporary track connecting module sections. If you want to get fancy, you can scenic the temp tracks too, kind of how Ken Patterson did his liftout sections in the August What's Neat. Ken built two liftouts for the same location ... one unscenicked and the other with scenery.

If you combine Ken's liftout techniques with your more permanent TOMA modules, you can see how you could make the temp connecting sections work as liftouts if you wish.

Keep in mind that unless you already know what your destination space will be like, there is always a chance one of your permanent TOMA module sections will not fit the new space. That's not a huge problem since you can harvest all the structures, trees, bushes, and details off the module (that's the really time consuming stuff any how) and just build a new TOMA module that will fit the new space.

One example of this for me on my new Siskiyou Line 2 (SL2) is Roseburg Yard. The yard is on a curve and I'm expecting the curved part to be throw away, but the end module sections with all the turnouts and yard ladders will be keepers. When I get to the new space, I will determine how the yard goes into the space and build a new center module to connect them.

So as I'm designing SL2, I try to make any module sections I expect to be throw away have few if any turnouts. I will be scenicking those throw away sections to match the rest of the layout, however.

Joe Fugate​
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine

[siskiyouBtn]

Read my blog

Reply 0
Kriegwulfe

Trade Out

Joe, like you alluded to, I was going to use TOMA to form the basis of my layout. I was then going to replicate one module and complete it and then place it in the layout, taking the " basic " model out, stripping it and then use it for a basis to complete another module and so on and so on. This allows independent work and still allows trains to be run, operations to be fine tuned , and modifications made without affecting anything on the layout itself. Kind of like a plug-n-play method of layout planning/building.

Reply 0
Moe line

Toma parts

Yannis, you have the exact right idea, on how the Toma concept works, and will be able to save most every section you build. Remember to keep the sections to a manageable size, most of my Toma sections are 24 inches wide and 48 inches long and made of lightweight materials to make them portable. They are also designed like a modular layout so that certain sections will match up with other sections, in many different configurations, I would make any temporary sections only about 8 inches wide, as they are just filler pieces,  with minimal scenery. Jim 

Reply 0
Yannis

Thank you all for the confirmation and insights!

Joe: Many thanks for the valuable pointers. I ll check out August's "whats neat" and see Ken's work. I am thinking along the same lines as you, to scenic the disposable modules and try to have as few turnouts as possible on them. Many thanks to MRH for the inspiration provided by the TOMA idea!

Moe: Thanks for the reply. I will indeed try not to overdo it with module lengths. So far the longest one is 5ft or so.

Kriegwulfe: Interesting approach/idea!

I ll get back to you sooner than later with the respective trackplans/modules!

Reply 0
Reply