ZimDalf

I am reading Carl Arendt's website carendt.com and came across this:

 

Kickback. More than a spur, less than a switchback. A spur formed with two frog-end facing switches, making a spur with both a facing-point and a trailing-point component. Very non-prototypical.

I don't understand this at all.  Can anyone explain it?

A picture would be awesome.

Reply 0
DougL

It is zig-zag trackage

It is zig-zag trackage  It looks like a switchback.

Imagine a Z.  From the base of the z you branch upwards to serve an industry.

Then you switch, and go along the top ot the Z to serve a second industry.

That second industry is on the "kickback spur".

The dotted line in this track plan is a kickback spur.  This forum post discusses it. 

_misc_66.jpg 

--  Doug -- Modeling the Norwottuck Railroad, returning trails to rails.

Reply 0
AnEntropyBubble

Doug, that makes more sense.

Doug, that makes more sense. Here's a sample I found in Calgary.

backspur.jpg 

Andrew

Reply 0
ZimDalf

Thanks!

Thanks!

Reply 0
BOK

We called them switch

We called them switch backs.

exprail

Reply 0
ZimDalf

Yes, exactly, that is what

Yes, exactly, that is what confused me.

I couldn't figure out what he meant by components. I don't see how it's not a switchback other then it's purpose is to set out cars on the spur, but the track configuration is the same as any switchback.

Reply 0
David Husman dave1905

Kickback not the same as switchback

Two completely different things.

A switch back is where the trains reverse directions to proceed.  Typically used in mountainous territory, typically on logging and mining railroads.

A kickback is a gravity operated switch back.  Typically they are used at car loading facilities, commonly on coal unloading piers.

Here is a picture"

The kickback is the curved track at the end of the pier, the cars are pushed up to the unoloader, unloaded then roll down the grade, through a spring switch, up onto the kickback which stops them and causeds them to roll back through the spring switch onto a grade down into a staging yard.

Here is a detail of a couple coal cars on the kickback, about to roll back, into the storage yard:

Dave Husman

Visit my website :  https://wnbranch.com/

Blog index:  Dave Husman Blog Index

Reply 0
skiwiggy

Kickback in operation Philadelphia PA Coal pier

The youtube link shows a kickback in operation at the Conrail Coal Pier #124.  Also in the video is the ore loaders in operation along with the 3 foot gauge car pushers used to pull and push the loaded ore cars around the loop tracks.  The loop tracks are still intact unused however the ore loader and coal pier were dismantled a couple years ago.  

Greg Wiggins 

 

Reply 0
ZimDalf

Ah very cool. Now that makes

Ah very cool. Now that makes way more sense.

Reply 0
Oztrainz

And in model form...

Hi all, 

and here's a working gravity kickback in model form

This uses specially fitted coal skips. The small wheelbase of the coalskips enables the very tight vertical curves in the track. The falling grade beyond the switch is 1 in 7 or about 14%. This ensures that any skip that is towed beyond the switch will roll away and head onto the diverging track. 

The gravity-weighted switch mentioned previously cannot be used because of the light weight of the model skips, but is simulated with magnetic reed switches below the track triggering a servo to switch the point blades as the skip wheels approach the blades from each direction.

I hope that this might be of interest,  

 

Regards,

John Garaty

Unanderra in oz

Read my Blog

Reply 0
ZimDalf

Very good John! 

Very good John! 

Reply 0
Bernd

Another Model Kick-back

Here's another model version of a kick-back.

Bernd

New York, Vermont & Northern Rwy. - Route of the Black Diamonds - NCSWIC

Reply 0
Oztrainz

The McMyler

Hi Bernd and all,

I'd forgotten about the McMyler. It sure is an impressive piece of animation and modelling. 

A couple of things to notice when comparing it to mine:

  • the length of run required to handle the longer bogie cars is far longer than that required to handle shorter 4 wheel cars this is mainly due to the vertical curves having to be more gradual
  • Heavier HO cars enable the use of gravity or spring-loaded switches to set the route to the kickback receiving track. Because of the light weight of my coal skips (about 8 grammes empty) the use of a gravity weighted switch was not an option for my set up, so we went with servo control. 
  • In the real world where even a small coal skip weighs in at a couple of hundred pounds (100 kg+) it is relatibely easy to set the weight or spring on the switch so that a wagon can roll through it "wrong road" without derailing and that the blades will go back after the wheels have passed.. It is a whole lot tricker to do it in model form because mass and inertia do not scale linearly 
  • the "hit-uo" in the receiving siding has to be controlled. If the speed is too high then it is likely that you will have a derailment or smash up couplings on wagons because the energy from the incoming wagon has to go somewhere. A slower speed just sufficent to couple up the incoming wagons to the standing wagons is desirable and will result in far less problems in the receiving track, I sidestep this problem by ensuring that the previous empty skip is out of the way and on its way back up the incline before the the next skip arrives. 

I hope that this is of soem interest to anyone who wishes to try somethng similar,

Regards,

John Garaty

Unanderra in oz

Read my Blog

Reply 0
WMShayMan

Kick back/loader

That is really cool!

Leonard Lee Davis

Reply 0
linmark

John Garaty - Kickback .

John , There used to be a kickback in Rozelle  Sydney  , It was used for the coalies from Glenlee & the Western fields . Closed in the mid 90's when Glenlee closed & then all western coal was sent to Port Kembla .

 

Cheers  Tom  J .

Reply 0
Oztrainz

Thanks Tom

Hi Tom,

Thanks for that. I didn't know that there was a standard gauge version at Rozelle. I am assuming it was part of the Balmain coal loader operations? I'll have to do some searching for old photos. 

Regards,

John Garaty

Unanderra in oz

Read my Blog

Reply 0
Oztrainz

Found another kickback

Hi all, 

found another one here on Bernd's 'Gumstump & Snowhoe" thread at  https://forum.mrhmag.com/post/aggregate-company-tram-line-12191336 also on a ship loader for coal. It shoiuld also clarify the "switchback" and how it might be used on a model layout to gain height. 

I hope you enjoy a re-visit as much as I did,

Regards,

John Garaty

Unanderra in oz

Read my Blog

Reply 0
Reply