Home / Forums / Modeling general discussion / DCC signals & Track Ballast
DCC signals & Track Ballast

Sat, 2010-05-22 07:11 — bigstew
Hi Everyone!
I was recently talking to a very good friend in Pennsylvania about various types and brands of track ballast that is available in HO scale. He told me that he heard using real crushed stone for ballast could interfere with the DCC track signal getting to the locomotive decoder. I had never heard of that before and I was curious if anyone else had heard about it, or has had some experience using crushed stone ballast on a DCC layout. Any help or info would be appreciated. I'm getting close to doing some ballasting and I don't want to have to tear up track and ballast. It would be annoying to say the least!!
Best Regards,
BigStew. ![]()
>> Posts index
User login
Navigation
Recent blog posts
- ROCK RIDGE SCENERY UPDATE
- Bill Scobie's Rio Grande Southern
- Rooting Droid X , DCC enginedriver throttle and other MR applications
- First Formal Session on the 8th Sub
- Layout Tour
- From Bowser - Lew English Sr. passes away
- JL&T Railroad - Video Update #8
- Jerry's Hoboken RR
- Finally ... some more progress
- Custom HO Diesel Model Painting - Anyone Out There Do It?
Suggestion
Ask your friend for his source of information this issue and look for details. Possibly just opinion.
I have never found, "They say or I heard" groups.
There is a possibility of magnetic material in the “ballast' or maybe local dirt was used which could have magnetic particles in it. I have seen this issue inMRR magazine articles over the years when some people attempt to use local dirt and do not sift the material with a magnet.
Rich
Inside every older person is a younger person wondering,
what happened?
I thought...
I thought the point of the magnet was to remove any ferrous particles from soil or gravel, etc. collected from the outdoors. If there were charged particles in the "gravel" they would either be repelled or attracted depending on the charge, not?
You don't want any of this sort of debris to be attracted by OR to, the motors and electronics in locos!
Sounds like an urban legend
Joe Fugate
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine
Some rocks are conductive (a
Some rocks are conductive (a bit). I suppose, that really conductive rocks might do something to the DCC signal on the tracks, but it's hard to imagine anything other than copper ore being conductive enough to create a real problem in this area.
Charlie
Editor, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine
That is quite a load of
That is quite a load of stone someone is slingging around on you. I used real sand from my companies sand and gravel pit on my modules with great success. I used screened stone sieved to size for ballast and freight car loads. Like someone has suggested before. Run a good powerful magnet through it first. If the stone is washed and dried by a sand screw or log washer there will be less metal in it but it still will contain some metal dust. Never microwave your dirt or gravel. You will have a lazer light show inside your microwave. I work for a large sand and gravel producer as a mechanic and can tell you that there is tons of metal in our finished products. Bucket, jaw dies, chutes, and any other metal object wears from the material sliding and grinding over it. We get on average 3 months out of our cutting edges on our loaders. All that metal ends up somewhere. Most gets washed out with the silt and other waste.
Thank-You
Thanks to all who answered my post. I was pretty sure there wouldn't be any problems but I wanted to hear from others who may have had some experience with this subject. Thank-You Very Much!!!