Joe Atkinson IAISfan

The 2-mile-long Atlantic Spur has long been a bit of a thorn in my side.  Its location puts it in an aisle on my layout, so I've never been able to really do it justice, only modeling about the first 30" of the spur.  Which means I've never been able to model ADM's Harlan Elevator at the end of the spur (see  https://forum.mrhmag.com/post/iaiss-west-end-atlantic-spur-on-a-shelf-12196934 ).  A couple years ago, I had an idea:  If I couldn't include the elevator itself, at least I could model their cute little GE 45-tonner, ADM 4441, to suggest the presence of the elevator further up the line.

I'd read good things about Bachmann's 45-tonner, including the fact that it's a surprisingly good runner, so I picked one up a couple years ago.  I love watching those side rods as it works!  I call it my honorary steam locomotive.  During an operating session where I was hosting a group from Kansas City, Keith Jordan spotted the 4441 and very, VERY kindly offered to install sound in it.  It's a tiny little locomotive, with seemingly zero space for a Tsunami, capacitor, and speaker, but Keith had done a number of these installs, so I was more than happy to accept.

Now, two years later, I finally found time to detail, paint, and weather this model.  Photos will follow in a separate post.  

THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU to Keith for his kindness in doing this sound install for me.  The 4441 is a blast to operate with its Tsunami, and the tiny speaker sounds surprisingly good.  For those interested in doing a similar install, I included details on the decoder, speaker, and install at  [topic:id=16509] .

Joe Atkinson
Modeling Iowa Interstate's 4th Sub, May 2005
https://m.facebook.com/groups/iowainterstate4thsub

https://www.iaisrailfans.org/gallery/4thSub

My MRH blog index

https://instagram.com/iaisfan

Reply 0
Joe Atkinson IAISfan

Photos

First, a prototype photo from my friend Andy Brown:

...and a couple model pics.  The prototype is pretty simple, so I didn't have many changes to make.  I modified the pilots to match the prototype and added a horn from the parts bin.  Couplers are short-shank Kadees, but they're still too long due to the limited space between the pilots and the trucks, forcing the coupler mounts further out.  Paint is Testors light aircraft gray and light blue.  Lettering is from a Microscale N&W caboose set, with the "M" coming from a "W" that was flipped, cut in half, and repositioned so the first and last strokes were vertical.  The things some people won't do to keep from having to buy a decal set...

22%20(1).JPG 

Weathering was done with oils and PanPastels, though it looks like the oil wash in the grill is still wet in this pic.22%20(2).JPG 

Reply 0
trainmaster247

It looks really, nice any

It looks really, nice any videos of it running?

23%20(2).JPG 

Reply 0
Chuck P

Question

I love the engine and love the effort that went into replicating it (including sound). I'm seeing a yellowish body color on the prototype and gray for the model. Any reason it's different?

Charles

HO - Western New York - 1987 era
"When your memories are greater than your dreams, joy will begin to fade."
Reply 0
Joe Atkinson IAISfan

Color

Quote:

I'm seeing a yellowish body color on the prototype and gray for the model. Any reason it's different?

I could be wrong, but I believe that's a difference in lighting.  Every ADM locomotive I've seen has been light gray and light blue.  Here's another Andy Brown pic of the 4441 from the dark side.

dy-Brown.jpg 

Something else to note is the highlighting on top of the model (e.g. atop the headlight enclosures), where it's getting more direct light.  To my eye, that looks more like the color in that first prototype pic taken in direct sunlight.

Reply 0
mesimpson

45 tonners are neat

Thanks for the photos of the prototype and model Joe.  I have 3 of them: 2 will become HBM&S 100 and 101, the third will likely become HBM&S 90, a GE 600V electric that appears to have used the same frame as the 45T.  My prototypes didn't have the side rods but I think I'll keep them on the 100 and 101, they are neat to watch flailing around.  I'll remove them from the 90, need 44T/70T sideframes on it.  

I am interested in the sound aspect of the 45T, will be using the linked page as a guide for the eventual installation, thanks for that link. 

Don't expect to move many cars with this unit, I max mine out pulling 3 cars, and it slips on any sort of grade.  Probably much like the prototype does actually.  They also don't like dead frogs on turnouts as the wheelbase is too short to get across without stalling occasionally.  Maybe I'll run a triple header of 45 tonners pulling a massive 9 car train around the layout...

Marc Simpson

Reply 0
Joe Atkinson IAISfan

@Marc

Thank you Marc.  If I can't have the elevator, it's nice to at least have this little "mobile billboard" that says it's there.  And those siderods are so cool in action!  I don't blame you a bit for keeping them.

I'm surprised about your tractive effort experiences though.  I was thinking that mine was good for 7-8 cars.  Virtually all my cars are equipped with Intermountain metal wheels though.  Agreed on the turnout issues, but all my frogs are powered.

 

Reply 0
gregcochenet

Lucky 7

Great post, Joe!  Thanks for posting the follow up articles about the spur and sound installation.  I bought the DCC critter last year and love it!  I consistently can pull 7 hoppers with it and hope to put sound in it soon.

Greg

0outline.png   

Greg Cochenet​

Route of the Fox River... follow the fox!

Reply 0
mesimpson

all metal wheels as well

I have found any grade and the 45T starts slipping with more than 3 cars, I have a bit of up and down in the area where I did some test runs.  If it's dead flat it might do better.  It isn't really and issue for me as the 45T were used to haul slag with 3-4 thimble cars which are tiny:  http://www.shapeways.com/product/89VREEK4U/slag-car-ho?li=user-profile&optionId=40971484 Thanks to Tim Schwartz for making these, a real treat since it is based on the cars my prototype used.  I think you should run a slag train around the layout Joe, it gives new meaning to a hot train...

Marc Simpson

Reply 0
Joe Atkinson IAISfan

Video

Quote:

It looks really, nice any videos of it running?

Here you go.  It's nothing special, but gives a glimpse of the siderods in action.

 

Reply 0
trainmaster247

Thanks! Again a great job,

Thanks! Again a great job,

23%20(2).JPG 

Reply 0
okiecrip

switcher

very nice switcher great sound 

Reply 0
Joe Atkinson IAISfan

switcher

Thank you okiecrip.  Keith did great work on the sound install.  I have to add that I was also really impressed with the engineering that Bachmann put into this.  Really pretty amazing what they crammed into such a small space.  Besides smooth slow-speed running, mine will pull around 7 covered hoppers.

Reply 0
David Husman dave1905

Nice engine

Looks like a nice little engine.

How will it be used during a session?

Dave Husman

Visit my website :  https://wnbranch.com/

Blog index:  Dave Husman Blog Index

Reply 0
quadk

Very impressive little guy

Very impressive little guy Joe!! That is also some very nice scenery you have done.

Kenny Ravenscroft
Pilar Valley Railway
 
Facebook Pilar Valley Railway Group
http://www.facebook.com/groups/433572426727477/

http://www.freewebs.com/quadk/

Reply 0
Joe Atkinson IAISfan

Thank you

Thanks very much Dave and Kenny.

Quote:

How will it be used during a session?

Good question Dave.  Unfortunately, given the limited space on the Atlantic Spur (shown below, right), I can only think of one way to use the 4441 during op sessions.

Since Harlan often requires one or two re-spots during a session, I thought of using the 4441's position to indicate that the elevator is ready for more empties, e.g. if it's in the clear on the Pellet Spur (on the left above), placed there by 0-5-0, the cars on the Atlantic Spur are loads that it brought down, and can be pulled.  I could then pull it out of Pellet and run up to the end of the Atlantic Spur, where more empties could be shoved against it for another trip up to the elevator.

I'd be grateful for other ideas.

Reply 0
Reply