Mycroft

Looking for contacts for this very special project.  To explain the project:

My Dad has a old Lionel HO (yes HO) steam engine.  Back when I was a teenager, the engine was not functional, and I took it apart and found out why - a plastic gear on the main drive axle was cracked, and instead of driving the main axle, would just spin in place.  The gear was removed and we attempted to find a replacement with no success.  The engine is still fine, but the gear has gone missing over the years.

It would seem to me that if a proper set of measurements could be generated, a replacement gear might be able to be made as a 3d print.  The gear is straight forward, hole in the middle which should press fit over the drive shaft, with simple teeth to engage the next gear on the outside.  Form the hole too small and repeatedly drill it larger until it fits properly.  (Maybe build a couple for trial and error.)

This project is not worth buying a 3d printer on it's own, but seems like a great use of the technology.  Who is available as a place to get this done, and what measurements would I need to get it done?  Or should I say, whom should my Dad contact - he still has the engine and is thinking of building a new layout of his own (maybe because of my participation here?)

Teaser:  I showed my Dad the article I have coming out in the Nov time frame.  He recognized the structure, having been there many times himself, from before I was born, until more or less modern times.  It got us talking about his future layout, and this old engine.

James Eager

City of Miami, Panama Limited, and Illinois Central - Mainline of Mid-America

Plant City MRR Club, Home to the Mineral Valley Railroad

NMRA, author, photographer, speaker, scouter (ask about Railroading Merit Badge)

 

Reply 0
Toniwryan

Dimensional data

The best thing you could do is actually design the gear in 3D CAD.  Once you have a 3D file of the gear, you have your choice of places to get it printed.  Shapeways would be one of the first choices.  Depending on the size, number of teeth, and thickness of the gear will determine the type of printer and material that will give acceptable results.

FreeCAD has an involute gear designer built in.

 

Toni

Reply 0
HVT Dave

Or you could buy a metal gear

NorthWest Short Line has a great selection of gears and quite likely one that will fit.

Also I had an old HO Lionel GS4 Daylight loco that was actually built by Bachmann and I sent it in for the $40 upgrade to a new loco.  (Just a thought if there is no sentimental value)

Regards,

Dave

Dave

Member of the Four Amigos

 

Reply 0
Mycroft

Sentimental value

 Since the engine belonged to my as a boy, and it is not now mine, I would say that sentimental value is attached to the engine.

James Eager

City of Miami, Panama Limited, and Illinois Central - Mainline of Mid-America

Plant City MRR Club, Home to the Mineral Valley Railroad

NMRA, author, photographer, speaker, scouter (ask about Railroading Merit Badge)

 

Reply 0
Mycroft

great info

 This is what I was looking for.  The project is out of my hands for the moment.  My Dad has the engine, and he spent some years working with CAD at his last job.  I downloaded Freecad, to check out, but sent him the link, and the overall plan.  I also sketched out an idea on how he could do it as an MRH article as well.  MRH, Father and Son authors.....  That would be a first.

James Eager

City of Miami, Panama Limited, and Illinois Central - Mainline of Mid-America

Plant City MRR Club, Home to the Mineral Valley Railroad

NMRA, author, photographer, speaker, scouter (ask about Railroading Merit Badge)

 

Reply 0
Reply