Michael Petersen petersenm

Spring switches are used by some prototype railroads to save the crew from having to re-align the switch points after passing through the switch.  The switch is sprung in one direction (typically the mainline), allowing any train to pass through the switch from the frog end without manually aligning the points.  When entering the mainline from a siding, this allows the train to continue on its way without having to realign the points to the main – the spring action takes care of this automatically.  Modeling this unique feature can be easily accomplished with an IR sensor and switch machine.

One approach to modeling a spring switch follows the prototype almost exactly – applying a spring force to the points.  However, since mass does not scale well, this can cause operational problems and derailments if the wheelsets cannot overcome the spring force on the points.  This approach may also require periodic adjustment of the spring tension.

Another approach is to use a motorized switch machine and simulate the behavior of the spring switch.  By actively driving the points the appropriate direction, the operational problems can be avoided while still maintaining the illusion of a spring switch.

This application uses a CKT-IRSENSE reflective infrared proximity detector to detect the approach of a train on the diverging route.   Normally, the points are aligned to the main track.  When a train is detected on the diverging route, the IR sensor shorts its output to GND, toggling the control input to an MRServo switch machine that controls the turnout, causing the points to align with the diverging route.  As long as the IR sensor remains covered, the points remain set for the diverging route.  Once uncovered, there is a programmable delay (up to 20 seconds) before the output of the IR sensor is released.  This allows time for the train to clear the points before they are automatically set back to the main route.

Manual control, to allow a train to take the diverging route when approaching from the point end of the switch, can be accomplished with a toggle switch wired in parallel to the IR sensor output.

A demonstration of this spring switch simulator can be see in the video below.  Upon the initial approach to the turnout, the IR sensor detects the train, causing the points to be set to the diverging route.  The points are then automatically set back to the mainline after a 4 second delay.  After traveling on the mainline, showing that the points do not change position, the switch is manually lined for the diverging route so the train can back in from the point end.

ure-line.png
Modeling the BJRY in Le Mars, IA
Co-owner of Iowa Scaled Engineering

ignature.png

Reply 0
BOK

That's a great way to do it

That's a great way to do it if you enjoy working with electronics.

However, a very simple way to achieve the same result is to merely use a light-tension, piece of spring wire about 2" in length and bent in a 90 degree angle on one end. This bent end is then placed in a centered hole in the throwrod (most ready to run turnouts/switches already have a center hole) and the remaining wire pointing to the frog and in between the rails is slightly bent to one side and either spiked or glued in position. The light spring tension from the bend in the wire should be just enough to move the points over with a wheel flange but not too much to cause a derailment.

This probably the easiest, most economical and simple method to change a manual switch to a spring switch.

I used this method for making spring switches in both HO and N scale, they always work beautifully and are a cinch to build. 

Barry

Reply 0
Michael Petersen petersenm

Re: That's a great way to do it

Agreed.  If you have a manual switch that you want to turn into a spring switch, that method may work very well, assuming one is also OK with the visual impact of the spring wire sitting between the rails.

However, for a switch that is already controlled with a switch motor, for example to set the diverging route manually, spring tension from the switch machine throw wire can be significant.  The solution above minimizes the operational risks involved with a pure mechanical solution.

 

Reply 0
ctxmf74

 "a very simple way to

"a very simple way to achieve the same result is to merely use a light-tension, piece of spring wire about 2" in length and bent in a 90 degree angle on one end. This bent end is then placed in a centered hole in the throwrod (most ready to run turnouts/switches already have a center hole) and the remaining wire pointing to the frog and in between the rails is slightly bent to one side and either spiked or glued in position. The light spring tension from the bend in the wire should be just enough to move the points over with a wheel flange but not too much to cause a derailment."

I've used a similar method in O scale by spiking a length of spring wire to the inside of the rail base so it pushes the points to the desired route. The key is have the points very free so they don't bind up and require too much spring pressure to close or too much flange pressure to open. The SP had some rubber switches on the coast line at one time but I don't know if UP retained them.....DaveB

Reply 0
Prof_Klyzlr

Another solution, no moving parts...

Dear MRHers,

Google "Dynamite Canyon Tramway"...

Happy Modelling,
Aim to Improve,
Prof Klyzlr

 

Reply 0
Reply