Tim Schwartz tschwartz

I had a question come my way about my 30 yard western, so here is a bit more information.

[attach:fileid=/sites/model-railroad-hobbyist.com/files/users/tschwartz/30-yard-real.jpg]

This is what I based the 30 yard western on, mostly photos with just a few actual measurements. The rest was scaled from all the photos.  

[attach:fileid=/sites/model-railroad-hobbyist.com/files/users/tschwartz/side-dumps.gif]

My 30 yard is on the left, 20 yard in the center and a difco on the right. I also did a "smooth side" dual air 30 yard western but I did not print it out yet. 

One thing about 3D work is you can use parts from one and put it on another item if you do it right.

The lift cylinders are the same for both the 30 yard and the 20 yard.

[attach:fileid=/sites/model-railroad-hobbyist.com/files/users/tschwartz/underside-30-yard.jpg]

A zoomed in view of the underside and you can see some of the detail I incorporated.

I had more detail for the 20 yard and based all the parts for the 30 yard from that. Simply "cut and paste" no drafting the part twice.

I mentioned before that this is printed as one piece. This was done to reduce warping of the finer details.It also means the center frame has the screw hole in it to screw it to the body. But you don't need to do that of course.

If you zoom in a bit on the 20 yard's lift cylinders you may be able to pick out the hinge is warped. I tried to straighten it as I glued it on, but that did not work well. Some other modelers printing 3d print sprues for strength. But that means more $$.

Whether you print as one piece or several pieces, there just isn't a cost savings. Remember you pay by cubic centimeters which is the same in both cases.

Now a friend and I have considered making a master and then getting some one to make molds of the pieces and cast all of it in resin or possibly metal for the main frame.

For now the 30 yard is a project on hold compared to my 85 ton steeple cab, but I will get it all painted and detailed later this spring. 

 

I hope that provides a bit more information for those that are interested in the car.

Until next time,

 

Tim Schwartz

Tim Schwartz Having fun in HO
Follow Me at Schist Lake Models 
Follow Me on YouTube 

Reply 0
Tim Schwartz tschwartz

Oops

Looks like you have to save a copy of the three side dumps to see all of them. Lesson learned.
Reply 0
Bill Brillinger

REsize

Tim, if you set the width of the wide image to 750 px, it will show the entire image and give the option to click it for the full size view.

Nice job on the cars too!

Bill Brillinger

Modeling the BNML in HO Scale, Admin for the RailPro User Group, and owner of Precision Design Co.

Reply 0
Milt Spanton mspanton

Thanks, Tim!  I appreciate

Thanks, Tim!  I appreciate the in-depth look, especially since you are trying to concentrate on the loco.

- Milt
The Duluth MISSABE and Iron Range Railway in the 50's - 1:87

Reply 0
Neil Erickson NeilEr

3-D Printing

Sorry to come in so late but what software do you use to draw? I have been spending more time on SketchUp than Acad lately so understand how components could save a lot of time. The issue for me is shipping. Are there places that will print at reasonable cost? Neil

Neil Erickson, Hawai’i 

My Blogs

Reply 0
Tim Schwartz tschwartz

Software

I use Alibre Personal Edition.

I get dinged with about $25 shipping from New York To Manitoba.

That is because I get hit with brokerage fees and duty and UPS shipping fees.

I use Shapeways as it is the least expensive for the quality. I have not been disappointed.

If you did not have a chance to read all my blog posts I talk about all that and more.

 

Enjoy 3D as it is the future.

Reply 0
Reply