Sugar Beet Guy

The following is a series of photos showing how I switch cars using “tab waybills”.  In this case, the waybills are ¾” Avery labels stuck on both sides of fender washers (two cycle waybills).  Enjoy or ignore, the choice is yours.

George Booth
Director of Everything, The New Great Western Railway
http://users.frii.com/gbooth/Trains/index.htm

George Booth
Director of Everything, The New Great Western Railway
http://users.frii.com/gbooth/Trains/index.htm

Reply 0
Sugar Beet Guy

Switching the Kelim Turn

The Kelim Turn is the most straight forward local on the Great Western.  It originates in the Loveland Yard, runs to Officer Junction and Kelim, then returns to Loveland, switching as needed along the way.

Since it is October and the GW’s locomotive fleet is busy with the beet campaign, the Colorado and Southern (a CB&Q subsidiary) has leased an 0-8-0 switcher to the GW for a few months. We will use this as power for the Kelim Turn.  The train is made up and the engine is serviced and ready.  The train is composed of four cars for the Birds District (red tabs) and four cars for the Union Pacific interchange at Kelim (white tabs). We leave the yard heading eastbound.  The yardmaster is busy assembling the Windsor Turn on the outside track (yellow tabs).

060.jpg 

The first location east of Loveland is the stock pens and feed storage area at Gorom. We have one car for the storage building (GO STO) and two outbound cars to pull but it is a facing point move in this direction so we will hold onto the car and do this work on the return trip.

061.jpg 

The Kuner’s Bean Warehouse is at Birds on the west side of the I-25 overpass and we have one car for it (BI KBN).  However, it is also a facing point move so we will again wait for the return trip.

062.jpg 

On the east side of the overpass is the Birds elevator (BI ELE).  This is a trialing point move so we can do some work here.  There is an outbound car ready to be pulled and moved back to Loveland yard where it will be added to the C&S southbound interchange (CS SOUTH).

063.jpg 

After a simple swap, we’re ready to couple up and head to Kelim.

064.jpg 

However, Kelim and the UP interchange are all facing point moves as we head into it so we first need to turn the entire train on the Officer Junction wye.  This is not immediately obvious to first time operators so it is noted on the train order card.

065.jpg 

Kelim has two industries on the rear track, Bumble’s Bean warehouse (KE BBN) and the Kelim elevator (KE ELE). The middle track is the UP interchange and has a string of outbound cars to be moved to Loveland.  The car at the elevator has a blank tab on it denoting it is being worked and will stay At the elevator this session.  We leave the train on the mainline and prepare to pick up the UP cars.

066.jpg 

After we pull the outbound interchange cars, we set out the inbound cars on the UP track. As we move the outbound cars, we noted that a box car for BBN was in the cut so we need to do some minor classifying to get things ordered correctly.

067.jpg 

We will need to pull the ELE car being worked, put the KBN and the new ELE car behind it and push them to their correct spots.

068.jpg 

And don’t forget to keep the Birds and Gorom cars up near the engine for the trip back!

069.jpg 

OK, that was a little more complicated than it seemed at first, but everything is spotted correctly and we are ready for the return trip.  

070.jpg 

After we cross the I-25 overpass at Birds, we have a simple trailing point drop at Kuner’s Beans (BI KBN).

071a.jpg 

Back at Gorom, we have one car to spot at the storage shed (GO STO, the old grounded box car), two cars to be picked up (the box car (LV PLT) and stock car (CS SOUTH)) and we need to leave the UP stock car where it is.  With the tab waybills, any car that is not being worked and is not at the location shown on the tab gets picked up and usually moved to Loveland.  The Loveland yardmaster will classify all inbound cars to the C&S interchange or top another GW train.

072.jpg 

A little pushing and pulling and we’re good to go.

073.jpg 

We’re back in the yard.  The yardmaster has the Windsor turn all assembled and blocked so we just need to drop our cars, turn the engine on the wye, let the hostler oil around, add coal and water and turn it over to the Windsor crew.  Job well done.  Go to beans!

074.jpg 

George Booth
Director of Everything, The New Great Western Railway
http://users.frii.com/gbooth/Trains/index.htm

Reply 0
RandallG

I'm happy that it works for

I'm happy that it works for you. Personally, it draws my eyes away from your nice scenery and details and towards all those nifty looking little price tags on all your rolling stock. Completely loses the modeling aspect for me.

Just my opinion though..

Randy

Reply 0
Dooch

Drawing eyes

To be fair, Randy, we are looking at the tags because all we see in the photos are switching operations, and because George is deliberately drawing our attention to them. When the trains are traveling between industries or towns I suspect we do see all that nice scenery. And when the operator is busy with a conventional card system, are his/her eyes not drawn away from the scenery too?
Reply 0
RandallG

I think your right Dooch.

I think your right Dooch. They just sort of grabbed my eye at first look and my brain wouldn't allow me to see the rest of the layout.  However, I'm sure that when viewed at a typical operating level you probably don't even notice them unless your looking for them.  Since they are color coded, perhaps even smaller tabs would be less conspicuous.

Randy

Reply 0
splitrock323

It only detracts in photos

Your system is great. It shows where cars are to spotted or pulled without a lot of paper work or bulky car cards. I have operated on many layouts that have great, award winning scenery, and the operators never notice as they are busy running their trains and planning their moves. Once people start operating, the looks of a layout tend to fade unless they have a road freight and can watch their train run from town to town. Thank you for sharing this. Thomas G.

Thomas W. Gasior MMR

Modeling northern Minnesota iron ore line in HO.

YouTube: Splitrock323      Facebook: The Splitrock Mining Company layout

Read my Blog

 

Reply 0
arthurhouston

This is Just Like car cards.

The same car goes in this case two places, this is why god created computer programs like JMRI operations. I agree distracts from a great looking model rr.

Reply 0
ctxmf74

Anyone ever tried

putting the tags on a clip board  lined up in the train order instead of on the model cars? As the train proceeds the tags on the board get re-arranged as the cars are switched. Seems like it would acheive the same book keeping results without the visual distraction?

Reply 0
Sugar Beet Guy

Same car two places?

Are you referring to the two-cycle nature of the tabs? Or something else?

Yes, the same car shuttles back and forth between the same two locations unless I move the tabs from car to car.  I see no problem with this. A car will require multiple operating sessions to repeat its cycle, especially if "work" tabs are used to hold it in a location for a session. Since different cars may have differing routes for a complete cycle (multiple trains, interchanges, etc) you rarely see the same cars in a particular train.  Even if that occurs, different operators may be running the trains on different sessions. And no one is likely to have memorized which cars were in a train the last time it was run.

So what's the problem? 

I prefer to see the tabs on top of the cars instead of car cards scattered all over the scenery and car card boxes stuck all over the fascia. 

George Booth
Director of Everything, The New Great Western Railway
http://users.frii.com/gbooth/Trains/index.htm

Reply 0
Art in Iowa

All tabs can be changed...

You can move tabs around on cars in between ops sessions. I personally like car cards cause there's nothing on a car to fall off, but I have used TOC in the past and it worked fine for me. I made up most of the tabs with paper and did the big-little-turn process outlined in MR years ago (looked like paper I beams).

Anything that lets you enjoy ops is worth it. Trying different systems is also great as well. Beats watching everything go around in circles... 

Art in Iowa

Modeling something... .

More info on my modeling and whatnot at  http://adventuresinmodeling.blogspot.com/

Reply 0
rbeagan

Tabs are a good start

Have not used tabs in fifty years, but they are a great way to start someone in operation so as to teach them the basics without all the paper work. At present I use a enhanced card system, which I enjoy. Have given thought of going back to car tabs but like the card system a little more. It is what makes you happy.

Reply 0
stevelton

I think it

makes it easier to see natural blocks of cars, and where to add pick-ups out on the road to put them with cars heading for a similar destination.

How to you keep the washers on the cars? Do they just sit there with nothing holding them on? If so, is there much problem of them falling off? This method seems better than drilling a small hole in the top of the car and using colored thumb tacks!

Steven

(Male Voice) UP Detector, Mile Post 2 8 0, No defects, axle count 2 0, train speed 3 5 m p h,  temperature 73 degrees, detector out.

Reply 0
Dooch

In defense of thumbtacks

Except for my 35 year hiatus, I have been using thumbtacks on my "lone wolf" layouts since Ed Ravenscroft first wrote about them in the 1960s. The most important statement made several times since I kicked off the waytag thread a couple of months ago is that each of us does what makes us happy. And that's good.

Should point out that since each of my freight cars is always adorned with a tack, no-one ever sees the hole! And as for "resale value" of cars with a hole, there isn't any even hole-free.

The great John Allen used paper waytabs. If George does as John did -- remove the tabs/washers/tacks before photos -- no-one would ever know about them except his operators, who like them.

This is the world's greatest hobby because there are SO many ways of doing EVERYTHING in it. Enjoy!

 

Reply 0
Reply