ctxmf74

    Hi All, I'm building a small layout with N scale code 55 turnouts and noticed that my old Lifelike GP-20 was bumping thru the frogs where my freight cars with low profile wheels were working fine. Checking the flanges on the loco they are deeper than my NMRA gauge so that's the problem. Does anyone know if later lifelike locos had smaller flanges, I like the SP bloody nose body on this one but I need to do something about the wheels. Maybe I could swap this SP body onto another drive or has anyone replaced these type with better wheels , or maybe filed or sanded the flanges down a bit? Do the later N scale locos from other companies have flanges that fit into the NMRA wheel gauges notches? I guess I should buy a new loco and see how they run thru the turnouts as I need a DCC equipped N scale loco anyway....DaveBranum

1990.jpg 
Read my blog

Reply 0
kcsphil1

Some do, some don't

Many of the more modern Kato and Atlas locos have smaller flanges, but few are specifically geared to run on code 55 straight from the box.  As you may recall Walthers bought Lifelike some time ago, so if parts were available then they'd be your source.  I don't believe that Walthers retooled the former LL locos.

One approach I've seen used successfully is to locat trucks on a newer locomotive and simple swap the out if the gear tower fits.  Of course, I have also seen people chuck teh wheel sets in a dremel tool and grind down the flanges,

Philip H. Chief Everything Officer Baton Rouge Southern Railroad, Mount Rainier Div.

"You can't just "Field of Dreams" it... not matter how James Earl Jones your voice is..." ~ my wife

My Blog Index

Reply 0
ctxmf74

"Some do, some don't"

Thanks for the response. I guess I'll hafta check out new locos and look for one with smaller flanges. Maybe I can file down the GP 20 a bit and see how it works then, I mainly just like it for the low nose old school SP look........DaveBranum

Reply 0
ctxmf74

Problem solved

 I pulled off the shell and clamped the frame in my panavice then hooked up power leads and ran it while grinding the flanges down with a dremel disc. A bit of clean up with an emory finger nail board and sand paper and it's close to fitting in the  NMRA gauge wheel notches and doesn't bump over the frogs any more. I wouldn't recommend this approach to the squeamish as there's lots that can go wrong grinding on a tiny drive with a high speed cutting disc. The only mishap I had was sanding a tiny bit of skin off my finger :> ) ...DaveBranum 

Reply 0
Reply