Artimus Gordon
I need info regarding my Bachmann Diesel engine that has a slight CLUNKING noise both forward and reverse. The engine is a fairly new with "DCC on board". How do I make it run quietly . All suggestions are appreciated. Art
Reply 0
PeterU

Check the gears

Sounds like you have a cracked gear.

Peter Ulvestad

Reply 0
Nelsonb111563

Decoder!

If it's noisy at slow speed in both directions and seems to smooth out at the upper speeds, it is the fault of the decoder.  The decoders that Bachmann uses for their DCC Onboard line Is a very basic decoder and does not have the "supersonic" or "silent drive" built in to the decoder as more current offerings.  This is not meant that there is a problem with the decoders but the electrical "kick" that the Bachmann decoder gives the motor at slower speeds is at a frequency that can be heard by human ears.  The "silent drive" decoders give the motor the same "kick", but do so at a much higher frequency that can not be heard by us.  That will be the buzzing or it may even sound like gears grinding at slow speed.  Bachmanns at top speed tend to have more gear noise but then again, most locomotives at top speed will have some gear noise. 

P.S.  Bachmann non-sound decoders are made by Lenz.

http://www.dccwiki.com/High-Frequency_Decoders

Nelson Beaudry,  Principle/CEO

Kennebec, Penobscot and Northern RR Co.

Reply 0
Nelsonb111563

Having read the first post and commenting on the 2nd....

I think Peter is on the right path with a possible craked drive axle gear or gears.  Run the locomotive slow on level track and see if the trucks "jump" slightly when you hear the clunk sound.  If so, it's time for a trip Back to Bachmann or replacement gears from NWSL.

Nelson Beaudry,  Principle/CEO

Kennebec, Penobscot and Northern RR Co.

Reply 0
Artimus Gordon

Noisy Bachmann

Thank you very much for your reply. It is greatly appreciated. The .frame is a split unit and I really don't. Have the expertise to take it apart and replace the gears. Are there how-to articles? I was thinking of replacing the decoder with a sound unit. Do you have a recommendation ? Thank you. ART
Reply 0
Artimus Gordon

Noisy Bachmann

Thank you for your answer . Is there a"how-to" on replacing the gears? ART
Reply 0
Artimus Gordon

Noisy Bachmann

I went to the "DCCwiki" web site that you recommend. Lots of info! But they recommend removing the capacitors when using a high frequency decoder. Question, what are the capacitors used for on an original engine? Do they prevent stalling? Thank you. ART
Reply 0
Terry Roberts

Interferance

I believe they are there for reducing interference with other electronic devices as the size is too small to store enough energy to prevent stalling. 

They weren't there for a lot of years before the FCC started pushing RF interference standards.

Terry

Reply 0
Artimus Gordon

Noisy Bachmann

Thank you for your reply. ART
Reply 0
bapguy54

I have a split frame GP30

I have a split frame GP30 that was noisy as well. I replaced the DCC on board with a Tsunamia sound decoder. After installation, I ran the loco on a loop of track at slow speed for 20 minutes, then half speed for 20 minutes then full speed for 20 minutes. I then did this procedure with the loco running in reverse. This quieted down the loco a lot. Joe.

Reply 0
Jurgen Kleylein

RF interference

The capacitors are required by European regulation to prevent RF interference.  I don't think they are required in North America.  They have no function as far as the operation of the motor or model are concerned.

Jurgen

HO Deutsche Bundesbahn circa 1970

Visit the HO Sudbury Division at http://sudburydivision.ca/

The preceding message may not conform to NMRA recommended practices.

Reply 0
Reply