Home / Forums / Locos and rolling stock / Which Tank cars do I use?
Which Tank cars do I use?

Mon, 2009-06-08 13:28 — kcsphil1
So as I was setting up a few tank cars over the weekend to begin figuring out how to space my unloading platforms, it occured to me that I haven't yet got a firm handle on what kind of tank cars I need, exactly. I'm modeling N Scale and the modern era (mid 1990's through about 2008) and I've built a small refinery complex that would be taking crude oil and turning it into a variety of refined liquid (and perhaps solid) products. Obviously my ADM tank cars won't find a home here (corn syrup not being petrol based) but other then that I have to confess I have little to go on in the way of lengths, reporting marks and the like.
So I'm turnign to you all, and waiting eagerly for answers.
Thanks!
>> Posts index
User login
Navigation
Recent blog posts
- ROCK RIDGE SCENERY UPDATE
- Bill Scobie's Rio Grande Southern
- Rooting Droid X , DCC enginedriver throttle and other MR applications
- First Formal Session on the 8th Sub
- Layout Tour
- From Bowser - Lew English Sr. passes away
- JL&T Railroad - Video Update #8
- Jerry's Hoboken RR
- Finally ... some more progress
- Custom HO Diesel Model Painting - Anyone Out There Do It?
Oil Refineries
Crude oil would most likely come in via pipeline (some refineries may receive trainloads of crude (eg. SP's "oil cans" unit trains)). They are also often located on a navigable river or lake, and ship a lot by water (tanker vessels).
Products like gasoline, diesel, asphalt are shipped in general service non-pressurized tank cars (like Atlas's 20K GATC and 25K ACF tanks, and Athearn's 25K RTC).
Liquified petroleum gas (LPG - propane, butane etc.) is shipped in large 30-33K pressurized tank cars.
Sulphur is a common byproduct, especially from so-called "sour" crude ("sweet" crude has low sulphur content, "sour" crude has a high sulphur content). This is shipped out in tank cars in molten form. Walther's 16K tank car is a good stand in for a lot of sulphur tank cars and comes decorated in several sulphur schemes.
Chris van der Heide
CPR Sudbury Division (Waterloo Region Model Railway Club)
Canadian Freight Car Gallery
Packaged Products
Note that it would also be possible to have a packaging plant for bottled or barrelled products like motor and lube oils. This could ship by truck and/or boxcar.
It might also received plastic pellets, unless the refinery also produces chemical products like plastics.
Gasoline additives would also be received at refineries via tank car. Today that might include ethanol, which is blended into some companies' gasoline. There's also a nice photo of a Dupont Canada (DOCX) tank car for Anti-Knock Compound in the Canadian Railways Color Guide to Freight and Passenger Equipment Vol 1 (published by Morning Sun books)
Chris van der Heide
CPR Sudbury Division (Waterloo Region Model Railway Club)
Canadian Freight Car Gallery
Many thanks!
Those are just the guidelines I was looking for. Maybe I'll restencil the ADM car for ethanol service . . . . .
Philip H. Chief Everything Officer Baton Rouge Southern Railroad, Mount Rainier Div.
There was a piece in last
There was a piece in last month's issue of trains about a shortline that was making some pretty good money hauling oil because production was far exceeding the pipeline available.
I think it was the "South Kansas & Oklahoma" railroad. The cars are unloaded onto trucks at a transfer facility which then haul the rest of the way to the refinery. The storey which discusses it starts on page 44 of the June 2009 issue. Maybe the library will have it?
I am not an expert on tank cars.. the image in the article shows one numbered "TILX 195145" with a 30070 US gallon capacity. Maybe someone who has the issue and knows tank cars can comment further? It looks a lot like the LPG cars I see a lot around New England.
Chris
“If you carry your childhood with you, you never become older.” My modest progress Blog
Ethanol and LPG cars
Wouldn't be an LPG car. LPG (propane or similar) is a compressed gas, so shipped in pressurized cars. This is an example of a Trinity LPG car, note there are no bottom outlets or pressure release vents along the top of the car. Most pressurized cars have a similar-looking dome covering the loading/unloading fittings.
http://freight.railfan.ca/cgi-bin/image.pl?i=tilx301521&o=tilx
Crude oil is obviously a liquid and could not be shipped in the same car. The car would have to be a general service type car, probably similar to 30K cars used for ethanol.
This car below is an ethanol car. Note the bottom outlets in the middle of the car for unloading liquid commodities.
http://freight.railfan.ca/cgi-bin/image.pl?i=tilx192844&o=tilx
Athearn has some modern tanks that represent a Union Tank Car (UTLX) version of an 30K ethanol car.
Chris van der Heide
CPR Sudbury Division (Waterloo Region Model Railway Club)
Canadian Freight Car Gallery
The ones in the picture
The ones in the picture shipping oil look just like this athearn ethanol car
http://www.trainsetsonly.com/page/TSO/PROD/ATH-10595
Even the number is close. I suspsect the same style cars are used for ethanol service.
Chris
btw - i Just found that link by searching google.. I don't know that vendor from a hole in the wall. Dont consider this a recommendation!
“If you carry your childhood with you, you never become older.” My modest progress Blog
Oil Refineries.
Awsome, you just answered alot of questions i had to chris concerning tanks, thansk a bunch!