MRH

2013-p10.jpg  Click to read this in landscape orientation …Click to read this in portrait orientation …

Read this issue!


Please post any comments or questions you have here.

Reply 0
arthurhouston

Article Gets a Zero

Will explain to Joe.

You made a cardinal mistake.

Reply 0
herronp

Huh?

I'm lost!   Peter

Reply 0
Dave O

Sorry mate ...

... a "1" is as low as you can vote ... a 'no vote' doesn't count ...

 

Reply 0
Yaron Bandell ybandell

Monthly or Not

The monthly format is nice, but I think that a format similar to web magazines like WIRED could work as well. The monthly format is likely easier to sell to advertisers since you can say the PDF was downloaded X amount of times. While with a web magazine format (like WIRED) you can try and attract people to come back and browse your site daily as opposed to once a month by slowly rotating your new articles onto the front page. Ofcourse that means advertisements and their campaigns might have to be setup differently than with a PDF version. Advertisers could still have a monthly campaign or could campaign against older articles (something which is not possible now since the PDF is static once generated) but accounting for how many people see their ads would need a major overhaul. Articles likely would have to be setup for individual downloads instead for those who want to be able to read them offline as well.

This months MRH indicates: the forums are a great source of information in between MRH issues, but many seem to not even look at them. Trying to get people to get to the site daily versus monthly might have people browse around longer leading to more ads being shown.

Either way, MRH is a really great source of information and I'll keep reading it in whatever format it is published. Keep 'em coming!

Reply 0
joef

What Art means

What Art means is his blog didn't make our list in staff notes. Honestly, a lot of very nice threads and blogs didn't make the list. Our intention was not an exhaustive list of threads and blogs but a list of posts made in the last couple of days to give people a flavor of what is on here. We went from the front to 4 pages in from the front of recent posts about 8 days ago. If you hadn't posted anything recently, then you didn't make the list. It's that simple. If you think this list is only the good ones and anyone else is somehow second rate, then you have got it all wrong. Frankly we were under the gun to get something into staff notes and we decided to promote the website. So we started pulling links from page 1 of recent posts, looking for posts with photos and how-to content primarily. Once we gat back to page 4 we were out of room so we stopped. This is convention season and we're especially under the gun to get an issue out. We appreciate all your posts, especially if you didn't make the list. While we can list samples to get people to come look see ... It's your continued posting - all of you - who will keep them coming back. If we thought people were going to hold our feet to the fire over this list, we would not have done it. By the way, none of the staff's posts are on this list either.

Joe Fugate​
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine

[siskiyouBtn]

Read my blog

Reply 0
stevelton

I think the article

did its job just fine. I like the mag being monthly, then I can come to the website for my daily fix! And there are lots of blogs on here, some are good, some are great, and some are a good attempt.

Steven

(Male Voice) UP Detector, Mile Post 2 8 0, No defects, axle count 2 0, train speed 3 5 m p h,  temperature 73 degrees, detector out.

Reply 0
wp8thsub

No worries, I hope

Quote:

If we thought people were going to hold our feet to the fire over this list, we would not have done it.

I had to go back and look to see if one of my blog entries was listed.  One was, but regardless of that the point is still the same.  You can only give so many examples, and I figured the selection was probably not intended to imply one blog post is somehow superior to another.

Rob Spangler MRH Blog

Reply 0
Dave O

Perhaps a joke ...

... that somehow got off-track ...

Reply 0
joef

Please go vote on this poll

We've started a poll to see how many feel MRH publishing such a list was a bad idea. Please go here and vote:

[topic:id=14473]

Joe Fugate​
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine

[siskiyouBtn]

Read my blog

Reply 0
Art in Iowa

Well, for the record...

stay monthly. People can do some clicking and get on the blogs and forums. Not that hard. But the mag should stay monthly. Alot less stress on the staff. I'm sure they get beat enough by Joe already and morale will not improve no matter what... 

Art in Iowa

Modeling something... .

More info on my modeling and whatnot at  http://adventuresinmodeling.blogspot.com/

Reply 0
Geared Steam

Cardinal mistake......

I don't believe so, the general sampling of recent posts, no big deal.

-Deano the Nerd

"The true sign of intelligence is not knowledge but imagination."-Albert Einstein

http://gearedsteam.blogspot.com/

[two_truckin_sig_zps05ee1ff6%2B%25281%2529]

Reply 0
arthurhouston

Beauty Contest

Do not judge a beauty contest their can only be one winner and many losers. 

Reply 0
joef

Don't agree

Quote:

Do not judge a beauty contest their can only be one winner and many losers. 

If you are comparing our blog list to a beauty contest, then I don't agree at all. Our list was not a competition and there were no judges, just Joe Fugate spending 30 minutes quickly pulling some sample blogs off pages 1-4 of recent posts so he could get on with producing the rest of the magazine.

Since the list was not a competition and there was no panel of judges, then those who did not make the list are not losers - they just didn't happen to have posted recently enough to be on page 1-4 of recent posts.

If you're upset over not posting recently enough to be on page 1-4, then we're sorry, but "them's the facts" as we say.

Joe Fugate​
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine

[siskiyouBtn]

Read my blog

Reply 0
janbouli

You should really have a look

You should really have a look at other forum software, I don't use the forum because it is not intuitive to use, hard to find something, much to massive and the "tell me there is a reply " does not work. No problem tho I am a member of 3 forums that work for me.
Reply 0
Joe Brugger

Can you give some examples of

Can you give some examples of forums that you find easy to use?

Reply 0
joef

Specific examples on here

Quote:

"tell me there is a reply " does not work

Where are you seeing this option? We tried a module that had this function, but it only worked if you were the original poster, and the constant emails every time someone posted a response got really annoying so we turned it off. If this is still showing up somewhere, we need to know about it so we can remove it since it's been turned off.

It sounds like a good idea on the surface, but in practice if you're getting any amount of replies to your thread, the constant barrage of emails gets old really fast. It's not a feature that you want to use once you've tried it.

Joe Fugate​
Publisher, Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine

[siskiyouBtn]

Read my blog

Reply 0
UPWilly

Well, not to be ...

... confrontational, but I like the way Drupal works. I have visited many forums and have found them somewhat cumbersome as compared to Drupal, This format works for me. Although I do not like HTTP in the way it functions with hypertext format, the hypertext functionality of Drupal is something I have valued. What I value here more than Drupal is the wealth and quality of idea exchange. "To each his own". I am sure Drupal cannot be every bodies "cup of tea", but it works for me.

 

Bill D.

egendpic.jpg 

N Scale (1:160), not N Gauge. DC (analog), Stapleton PWM Throttle.

Proto-freelance Southwest U.S. 2nd half 20th Century.

Keep on trackin'

Reply 0
Reply