david.haynes

This is my last blog posting for this worked example of using JMRI Operations to create the switch lists for Lance Mindheim’s bakery switching layout.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

N scale, DCC-NCE, Switching, Operations

Reply 0
david.haynes

Part 5

In my last blog posting, I managed to get the box car traffic between Cassette and Bakery working the way I wanted it with a mixture of box cars and loads being dropped and picked up at Bakery. I had limited the number of box cars to five which matched the number of box car spots at Bakery.

Now I want to add more boxcars and restore the other traffic (covered hoppers and tank cars) to see how the mix of cars is handled. I start by adding the three more box cars (RBOX) and spotting the hoppers and tank cars at Cassette.

Cars%201.png 

I build the Bakery Turn job and preview the manifest.

fest%201.png 

This looks pretty good but I want to also build a schedule for the tank cars since they are most likely carrying different types of sweeteners – corn syrup in different grades, maltose, dextrose, fructose, etc.

So, I reset the build and create the tank car schedule and add the new load types to the Tank Food cars.

oads%201.png 

Then, I add a schedule for the tank cars to the Bakery.

dule%201.png 

I will leave the schedule mode at ‘Sequential’ for now to see what happens. I need to load up the tank cars in Cassette next.

dule%201.png 

I’m going to not set the destination track at Bakery to see what JMRI does.

Finally, I will set the load on some of the tank cars in Cassette.

Cars%202.png 

I build and preview the Bakery Turn job:

fest%202.png 

It looks like setting the schedule mode to ‘Sequential’ has caused only one tank car to be delivered. Since Bakery has four tank car slots, this is not really what I want. I reset the train build and set the schedule mode to ‘Match’.

fest%203.png 

That looks better.

So far, every car is fully loaded or unloaded at Bakery within a single turn. That is, a loaded car is unloaded by the time the next train arrives. What if I want some loads to take a little longer?

According to the JMRI operations help file, this is what the ‘Wait’ column in the schedule is for. The wait number is the number of trains before the car is available. I will test this by setting the wait value on the tank cars to two.

Building a number of Bakery Turn jobs show that the tank cars are only being moved from the Bakery on every second train.

I’m going to add a schedule for the grain hopper as well. I add the loads ‘Wheat’ and ‘MT’ to the grain hopper car type and then create a simple schedule.

Schedule.png 

I also make the corresponding change to the Cassette schedule.

dule%202.png 

At this point, I would probably give serious consideration to re-casting the Cassette spur as three different spurs (Cassette-HO, Cassette-TM, Cassette-XM) so that I could manage the schedules at a finer grain. For now, the single spur is enough.

To test everything so far, I reset all my cars as follows:

Cars%203.png 

The following table shows the traffic generated between Cassette and Bakery over a number of Bakery Turn jobs.

Bakery Drop Off

Bakery Pick Up

Turn

HO

TM

XM

HO

TM

XM

1

Wheat

Pie Filling, Shortening, Yeast, MT

2

Corn Syrup 100, Dextrose, Fructose

MT

MT

MT, MT, MT, Baked Goods

3

Wheat

Milk Powder, Pie Filling, Sugar, MT

Baked Goods

4

MT

MT, MT, MT, Baked Goods

5

Wheat

Shortening, Sugar, Sugar, MT

MT, MT, MT

Baked Goods

6

Corn Syrup 100, Corn Syrup 200, Corn Syrup 100

MT

MT

MT, MT, MT, Baked Goods

7

Wheat

Milk Powder, Sugar, Shortening, MT

Baked Goods

8

MT

MT

MT, MT, MT, Baked Goods

9

Wheat

Shortening, Sugar, Sugar, MT

MT, MT, MT

Baked Goods

10

Corn Syrup 100, Corn Syrup 200, Dextrose

MT

MT

MT, MT, MT, Baked Goods

This looks like a pretty good mixture to me. I could change the covered hopper load to more types of grain products: Durham, Semolina, Soft, Hard, etc. and add wait times to the Cassette spur schedule to mix up the traffic even more.

This is the last blog posting I plan on doing for this worked example. I have come a long way since loading JMRI onto my computer and wondering if it was really what I wanted to use instead of car cards.

For me, the answer has been a resounding ‘Yes’! JMRI has presented me with the tools I need to use for my switching operations and there is still much more to explore – yards, blocking, aggressive builds – the list continues to grow.

Before I conclude, I’d like to thank all the developers of JMRI – especially Dan Boudreau – for creating such a good, free program and answering my beginner questions in the JMRI forum. I’d also like to thank Lance Mindheim for advocating that complex operations do not require a lot of industries or track. Consider that, by move 9 above, I will have had to deal with nine cars and probably twice as many pull-push operations at the Bakery.  At switching speeds, that would easily take an hour of time to complete.

Finally, I would like to thank the members of the MRH forum (and MRH for hosting this blog) who have offered comments and suggestions. Keep ‘em coming guys!

I also have a question for the forum. Does anyone see any value in me bundling all these postings up into a PDF or other format document? I have all the original text and images saved, so it would not be that difficult.

-david-

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

N scale, DCC-NCE, Switching, Operations

Reply 0
gate5

PDF version

David;

If you already have all the material, I think a number of us would like to see the whole thing and print it out. Your writing and screen shots might help a number of people with the ops program.

 

Dick Foster

Sonoma CA

 

Dick Foster

Arrow Creek & Western 

Reply 0
dreesthomas

yes please do a PDF

An excellent presentation.  I hope that we'll get to see more as you explore JMRI.  I'm particularly interested in the problem of getting a car or cars delivered to a yard by one train then taken to their final destination on another subdivision by a second train.

Thanks for the work!

David

 

David Rees-Thomas
Reply 0
david.haynes

PDF

I'll check with MRH to see if they have any objections/concerns.

-david-

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

N scale, DCC-NCE, Switching, Operations

Reply 0
arthurhouston

Restrict what the Train does

Their are a ton of ways to restrict trains and cars. Suggest you join the JMRI Yahoo chat group and post your question about operations. The people that wrote it are their to help you and answer your questions.
Reply 0
david.haynes

Working on PDF

I checked with Joe Fugate and he is fine with me combining the blog postings into one document to make it easier to print out.

I can probably do a number of formats, does anyone have a strong need for something other than PDF? Epub and mobi would probably not be that hard...

-david-

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

N scale, DCC-NCE, Switching, Operations

Reply 0
Ken Glover kfglover

PDF works...

...for me. I want all of this in one place and if you are willing to do it, go for it!

Ken Glover,

HO, Digitrax, Soundtraxx PTB-100, JMRI (LocoBuffer-USB), ProtoThrottle (WiThrottle server)

View My Blog

20Pic(1).jpg

Reply 0
david.haynes

Problem with PDF

I have created the PDF. It runs 37 pages and just over 2MB in size.

The problem is that I don't see a way to push it to the MRH web site.

I will probably have to find another place to host it and link it in.

-david-

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

N scale, DCC-NCE, Switching, Operations

Reply 0
JimBrown

PDF file is available

I offered to host David's file, and he accepted.

You can find it here: Using JMRI Operations - A Worked Example

Note: Because it is a PDF file, simply clicking on this link will most likely open the file within your browser. If you wish to save the file to your computer, you can hover the mouse near the bottom of your browser window at which point a small overlay should appear. On the left of that overlay is an icon of disk. Click that to save the file. The other way to save the file to your computer is to right click the link above and select "Save Link as..." or words to that effect.

Regards,
...jim

 

Reply 0
Ken Glover kfglover

Thanks, David and Jim

I got my copy with no problems. 

Ken Glover,

HO, Digitrax, Soundtraxx PTB-100, JMRI (LocoBuffer-USB), ProtoThrottle (WiThrottle server)

View My Blog

20Pic(1).jpg

Reply 0
Reply